How can you worship leeks and onions? we shall suppose a SORBONNIST to say to a priest of SAIS. If we worship them, replies the latter; at least, we do not, at the same time, eat them. But what strange object of adoration are cats and monkeys? says the learned doctor. They are at least as good as the relics or rotten bones of martyrs, answers his no less learned antagonist. Are you not mad, insists the Catholic, to cut one another's throat about the preference of a cabbage or a cucumber? Yes, says the pagan; I allow it, if you will confess, that those are still madder, who fight about the preference among volumes of sophistry, ten thousand of which are not equal in value to one cabbage or cucumber.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Hume argues that religious rituals and disputes are often arbitrary and less rational than mundane choices.
- In plain terms
- Fighting over religious symbols is irrational compared to everyday decisions.
- What can you take from it?
- Religious dogma often masks arbitrary preferences.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What makes a practice meaningful?
- When does ritual become absurd?
Another view
It dismisses the sincere meaning rituals hold for believers.
More from David Hume
To oppose the torrent of scholastic religion by such feeble maxims as these, that it is impossible for the same thing to be and not to be, that the whole is gr…
Permalink to quote #35 We may observe, that, notwithstanding the dogmatical, imperious style of all superstition, the conviction of the religionists, in all ages, is more affected th…
Permalink to quote #37 The heroes in paganism correspond exactly to the saints in popery, and holy dervises in MAHOMETANISM. The place of, HERCULES, THESEUS, HECTOR, ROMULUS, is now …
Permalink to quote #34
Related quotes
'Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. I did an original sin. I poked a badger with a spoon.' 'Say five Hail Mary's and six Hello Dolly's!'
Eddie IzzardEddie Izzard quote #9 That original intelligence, say the MAGIANS, who is the first principle of all things, discovers himself immediately to the mind and understanding alone; but h…
David HumeDavid Hume quote #33 Religion is too important a matter to its devotees to be a subject of ridicule. If they indulge in absurdities, they are to be pitied rather than ridiculed.
Immanuel KantImmanuel Kant quote #2