Skip to content
quotesby

I am a libertine, but I am not a criminal nor a murderer, and since I am compelled to set my apology alongside my vindication, I shall therefore say that it might well be possible that those who condemn me as unjustly as I have been might themselves be unable to offset the infamies by good works as clearly established as those I can contrast to my errors. I am a libertine, but three families residing in your area have for five years lived off my charity, and I have saved them from the farthest depths of poverty. I am a libertine, but I have saved a deserter from death, a deserter abandoned by his entire regiment and by his colonel. I am a libertine, but at Evry, with your whole family looking on, I saved a child-at the risk of my life-who was on the verge of being crushed beneath the wheels of a runaway horse-drawn cart, by snatching the child from beneath it. I am a libertine, but I have never compromised my wife's health. Nor have I been guilty of the other kinds of libertinage so often fatal to children's fortunes: have I ruined them by gambling or by other expenses that might have deprived them of, or even by one day foreshortened, their inheritance? Have I managed my own fortune badly, as long as I have had a say in the matter? In a word, did I in my youth herald a heart capable of the atrocities of which I today stand accused?... How therefore do you presume that, from so innocent a childhood and youth, I have suddenly arrived at the ultimate of premeditated horror? No, you do not believe it. And yet you who today tyrannize me so cruelly, you do not believe it either: your vengeance has beguiled your mind, you have proceeded blindly to tyrannize, but your heart knows mine, it judges it more fairly, and it knows full well it is innocent.'

Donatien de Sade#2

MoralityApologyCharityReputation

About this quote

What does it mean?
An apology defending a reputation by contrasting personal faults with good deeds.
In plain terms
I admit my flaws but list my good acts to balance the score.
What can you take from it?
Contextualize personal faults by highlighting contributions and charity.

Where it applies

  • public defense
  • confessional writing

Putting it to work

  • highlight contributions when criticized
  • acknowledge faults publicly

Questions to consider

  • Does good work outweigh bad behavior?
  • How should apologies be structured?

Another view

Charity does not necessarily absolve ethical wrongdoing.

More from Donatien de Sade

  1. The law which attempts a man's life [capital punishment] is impractical, unjust, inadmissible. It has never repressed crime-for a second crime is every day com…

    Permalink to quote #1
  2. Le duc imita bientot avec Bande-au-ciel la petite infamie de son ancien ami et il paria, quoique le vit fut enorme, d'avaler trois bouteilles de vin de sens fr…

    Permalink to quote #3
  3. Nos quatre libertins, a moitie ivres, mais resolus pourtant d'observer leurs lois, se contenterent de baisers, d'attouchements, mais que leur tete libertine su…

    Permalink to quote #4

Related quotes

  1. I think that Jesus would be disappointed in our ignoring the plight of those around us who are suffering and our focus on our own selfish short-term needs. I t…

    John EdwardsJohn Edwards quote #1
  2. I did not write those letters. This has been a hoax that I've had nothing to do with. I'm sorry it's gone on as long as it has.

    Thomas PynchonThomas Pynchon quote #5
  3. With one hand he put A penny in the urn of poverty, And with the other took a shilling out.

    Robert PollokRobert Pollok quote #8