Skip to content
quotesby

He was, as painted, aristocratic, beyond any writer I've met, but in a Jeffersonian-American way that brooked no artificial distinctions. There was no cheap way you could impress him... It was a particular strength of his as a critic that he was not even impressed by the Dead as such. He could write of living authors in precisely the same tones, and applying the same standards, as he used for the Classics.

Edmund Wilson#5

CriticismEqualityIntegrityStandards

About this quote

What does it mean?
Wilson praises a critic for treating living and classic authors with equal rigor, refusing to be impressed by fame alone.
In plain terms
He judged all writers by the same high standard.
What can you take from it?
Fairness in critique transcends status.

Where it applies

  • art evaluation
  • peer review

Putting it to work

  • applying consistent criteria

Questions to consider

  • What defines a good critic?
  • Should fame influence judgment?

Another view

This ignores the difficulty of judging contemporary work.

More from Edmund Wilson

  1. Marxism is the opium of the intellectuals.

    Permalink to quote #4
  2. Wilson was not, in the academic sense, a scholar or historian. He was an enormous reader, one of those readers who are perpetually on the scent from book to bo…

    Permalink to quote #6
  3. It may be that there is nothing more demoralizing than a small but adequate income.

    Permalink to quote #3

Related quotes

  1. Do what you feel in your heart to be right - for you'll be criticized anyway. You'll be 'damned if you do, and damned if you don't.'

    Eleanor RooseveltEleanor Roosevelt quote #1
  2. Not long ago the head of what should be a strictly scientific department in one of the major universities commented on the odd (and ominous) phenomenon that pe…

    Revilo P. OliverRevilo P. Oliver quote #2
  3. I'd rather have a hundred thousand or a million people saying I'm nuts and I'm crazy for my musical choices and what I've said lyrically, than a million people…

    Chuck DChuck D quote #4