Skip to content
quotesby

Ernest Bramah's China, then, is the fantastic bogus China of convention, not the real historical thing at all. He wrote of it in a prose so perfectly conceived that it becomes a miracle of style. As Hilaire Belloc once observed, the sly humor and philosophy of Bramah's stories is a trick he achieves by pretending to adapt the flavor of Chinese literary conventions into the English. But the thing I love most about the tales is their irony and the brilliance of their wit.

Ernest Bramah#25

LiteratureCriticismFictionHumorStyle

About this quote

What does it mean?
This critic praises Bramah's China for its stylistic brilliance and wit, rather than historical accuracy.
In plain terms
Bramah's China is fake but written beautifully with humor.
What can you take from it?
Style can matter more than accuracy.

Where it applies

  • reading fiction
  • writing style
  • cultural representation

Putting it to work

  • focus on style
  • evaluate fiction

Questions to consider

  • Is fake culture acceptable in fiction?
  • Does style justify content?

Another view

Cultural stereotypes in fiction can still be harmful despite the humor.

More from Ernest Bramah

  1. 'When an alluring woman comes in at the door,' warningly traced the austere Kien-fi on the margin of his well-known essay, 'discretion may be found up the chim…

    Permalink to quote #24
  2. Bramah's books fall into two very unequal categories. Some, fortunately the smaller part, record the adventures of the blind detective, Max Carrados. These are…

    Permalink to quote #26
  3. Better a dish of husks to the accompaniment of a muted lute than to be satiated with stewed shark's fin and rich spiced wine of which the cost is frequently me…

    Permalink to quote #23

Related quotes

  1. 'I'm an owl; you're another. Sir Critic, good day.' And the barber kept on shaving.

    James Thomas FieldsJames Thomas Fields quote #2
  2. Dr. Kettle was wont to say that Seneca writes as a Boare does pisse, scilicet by jirkes.

    John AubreyJohn Aubrey quote #7
  3. Bolano's narrative style is fragmented and loaded. It is also full of a strange kind of gallows humour, as we are swept along by stories that are invented and …

    Roberto BolanoRoberto Bolano quote #10