Who imagines that there exist any common ideals of distributive justice such as will make the Norwegian fisherman consent to forego the prospect of economic improvement in order to help his Portuguese fellow, or the Dutch worker to pay more for his bicycle to help the Coventry mechanic, or the French peasant to pay more taxes to assist the industrialization of Italy? If most people are not willing to see the difficulty, this is mainly because, consciously or unconsciously, they assume that it will be they who will settle these questions for the others, and because they are convinced of their own capacity to do this justly and equitably.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- People support distributive justice believing they can decide fairly for others, ignoring that most will not voluntarily pay to help strangers.
- In plain terms
- People think they can judge fair pay for others because they want to be the ones deciding.
- What can you take from it?
- Support for redistribution often assumes a position of power.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Why do people support forced fairness?
- Can we judge for others?
Another view
Some may genuinely value altruism over self-interest.
More from Friedrich Hayek
The problems raised by a conscious direction of economic affairs on a national scale inevitably assume even greater dimensions when the same is attempted inter…
Permalink to quote #27 To undertake the direction of the economic life of people with widely divergent ideals and values is to assume responsibilities which commit one to the use of …
Permalink to quote #29 If we were to make no better use of victory than to countenance existing trends in this direction, only too visible before 1939, we might indeed find that we h…
Permalink to quote #26
Related quotes
In the usual (though certainly not in every) public decision on economic policy, the choice is between courses that are almost equally good or equally bad. It …
John Kenneth GalbraithJohn Kenneth Galbraith quote #1 Obviously, crime pays, or there'd be no crime.
G. Gordon LiddyG. Gordon Liddy quote #1 Aggression unopposed becomes a contagious disease.
Jimmy CarterJimmy Carter quote #2