Skip to content
quotesby

So you want to live 'according to nature?' Oh, you noble Stoics, what a fraud is in this phrase! Imagine something like nature, profligate without measure, indifferent without measure, without purpose and regard, without mercy and justice, fertile and barren and uncertain at the same time, think of indifference itself as power - how could you live according to this indifference? Living - isn't that wanting specifically to be something other than this nature? Isn't living assessing, preferring, being unfair, being limited, wanting to be different? And assuming your imperative to 'live according to nature' basically amounts to 'living according to life' - well how could you not? Why make a principle out of what you yourselves are and must be?

Friedrich Nietzsche#128

PhilosophyEthicsNatureContradictionStoicism

About this quote

What does it mean?
Nietzsche mocks the Stoic claim to live 'according to nature', arguing that nature is indifferent and chaotic, making such a principle contradictory.
In plain terms
Living by nature is impossible because nature is indifferent and chaotic.
What can you take from it?
Question vague ideals that ignore reality.

Where it applies

  • ethical debates
  • personal philosophy

Putting it to work

  • examine assumptions
  • align actions with reality

Questions to consider

  • What does 'nature' truly mean for us?
  • Can we find a workable middle ground?

Another view

Some find value in aligning with natural rhythms despite chaos.

More from Friedrich Nietzsche

  1. It is some basic certainty which the noble soul has about itself, something which does not allow itself to be sought out or found or perhaps even to be lost. T…

    Permalink to quote #127
  2. Physiologists should think twice before positioning the drive for self-preservation as the cardinal drive of an organic being. Above all, a living thing wants …

    Permalink to quote #129
  3. Then will he who goes under bless himself for being one who goes over and beyond; and the sun of his knowledge will stand at high noon for him.

    Permalink to quote #126

Related quotes

  1. Of late, men seem to have been possessed by an incomprehensible impulse to strip themselves of everything with which nature has endowed them in order to make t…

    Eugene DelacroixEugene Delacroix quote #2
  2. The end and aim of the Cynic philosophy, as indeed of every philosophy, is happiness, but happiness that consists in living according to nature, and not accord…

    JulianJulian quote #5
  3. Truth, Goodness, Beauty - those celestial thrins, Continually are born; e'en now the Universe, With thousand throats, and eke with greener smiles, Its joy conf…

    Henry David ThoreauHenry David Thoreau quote #13