Skip to content
quotesby

Shaw knows at any moment, on any subject, what he thinks, what you will think, what others have thought, what all this thinking entails; and he takes the most elaborate pains to bring these thoughts to light in a form which is by turns abstract and familiar, conciliatory and aggressive, obvious and inferential, comic and puzzling. In a word, Shaw is perhaps the most consciously conscious mind that has ever thought - certainly the most conscious since Rousseau; which may be why both of them often create the same impression of insincerity amounting to charlatanism. Yet it is by excess of honesty that Shaw himself lent color to his representation as an inconsequential buffoon bent on monopolizing the spotlight.

George Bernard Shaw#248

TruthCriticismWritingIntentionPersonality

About this quote

What does it mean?
This text describes Shaw as hyper-aware of thoughts but potentially seeming insincere or performative due to excess honesty.
In plain terms
Shaw knows so much about thinking it seems like a trick, but he is just overly honest.
What can you take from it?
Being too transparent can look like acting or trickery.

Where it applies

  • literary criticism
  • public speaking
  • biography

Putting it to work

  • manage public image
  • analyze author intent
  • understand critique

Questions to consider

  • Is honesty always good?
  • How do we judge sincerity?

Another view

The quote is a critique by someone else, not Shaw speaking directly.

More from George Bernard Shaw

  1. Seeing clearly within himself and always able to dodge around the ends of any position, including his own, Shaw assumed from the start the dual role of prophet…

    Permalink to quote #249
  2. Shaw's plays are the price we pay for Shaw's prefaces.

    Permalink to quote #247
  3. Shaw does not merely decorate a proposition, but makes his way from point to point through new and difficult territory.

    Permalink to quote #250

Related quotes

  1. One would have thought that the notion of an impersonal critic was as patently absurd as that of an impersonal person: yet playwrights still cherish it as a so…

    Kenneth TynanKenneth Tynan quote #14
  2. Every word she writes is a lie, including and and the.

    Mary McCarthyMary McCarthy quote #29
  3. Satire, though it may exaggerate the vice it lashes, is not justified in creating it in order that it may be lashed.

    Anthony TrollopeAnthony Trollope quote #74