One would have thought that the notion of an impersonal critic was as patently absurd as that of an impersonal person: yet playwrights still cherish it as a sort of holy ideal. Admittedly, we all make mystiques: but this one is particularly wishful. The man who asks for an anonymous, impersonal criticism is trying to elevate criticism to the status of a science; whereas it is, I am afraid, only an art. The critic's business is to write readable English: the playwright's to write speakable English. Beyond that it is every man for himself. (p. 61)
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Criticism is an art requiring readable writing, not a science demanding impersonal objectivity.
- In plain terms
- Criticism is personal art, not impersonal science.
- What can you take from it?
- Write readable, personal criticism instead of pretending to be neutral.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is your work trying too hard to be neutral?
- How does your voice affect your writing?
Another view
Some contexts like scientific review benefit from impersonal approaches.
More from Kenneth Tynan
The buttocks are the most aesthetically pleasing part of the body because they are non-functional. Although they conceal an essential orifice, these pointless …
Permalink to quote #13 Welles is at once as abnormal and as natural as Niagara Falls. (p. 65)
Permalink to quote #15 Judge and prosecutor had hammered it home that Lady Chatterly was an immoral woman, that she had had sexual relations before marriage, that she had committed a…
Permalink to quote #12
Related quotes
The dilemma of the critic has always been that if he knows enough to speak with authority, he knows too much to speak with detachment.
Raymond ChandlerRaymond Chandler quote #9 The best of our fiction is by novelists who allow that it is as good as they can give, and the worst by novelists who maintain that they could do much better i…
J. M. BarrieJ. M. Barrie quote #1 I regard criticism as an art, and if in this country and in this age it is practiced with honesty, it is no more remunerative than the work of an avant-garde f…
Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #1