The dilemma of the critic has always been that if he knows enough to speak with authority, he knows too much to speak with detachment.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- It describes the critic's dilemma: expertise undermines detachment while detachment limits authority.
- In plain terms
- A critic cannot be both fully knowledgeable and fully objective.
- What can you take from it?
- Expertise makes true detachment difficult in criticism.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can critics ever be objective?
- How do we value expert opinion?
Another view
It assumes knowledge always leads to a lack of detachment.
More from Raymond Chandler
[As a screenwriter] I have a sense of exile from thought, a nostalgia of the quiet room and balanced mind. I am a writer, and there comes a time when that whic…
Permalink to quote #8 By the way, would you convey my compliments to the purist who reads your proofs and tell him or her that I write in a sort of broken-down patois which is somet…
Permalink to quote #10 The perfect detective story cannot be written. The type of mind which can evolve the perfect problem is not the type of mind that can produce the artistic job …
Permalink to quote #7
Related quotes
One would have thought that the notion of an impersonal critic was as patently absurd as that of an impersonal person: yet playwrights still cherish it as a so…
Kenneth TynanKenneth Tynan quote #14 The best of our fiction is by novelists who allow that it is as good as they can give, and the worst by novelists who maintain that they could do much better i…
J. M. BarrieJ. M. Barrie quote #1 I regard criticism as an art, and if in this country and in this age it is practiced with honesty, it is no more remunerative than the work of an avant-garde f…
Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #1