[Social Security is] a Ponzi scheme -- named after Charles Ponzi, who set up a similar plan in Boston in 1920. He promised to pay investors 50% profit on their money in just 45 days. Gullible people poured money into his plan. But he couldn't possibly earn enough on the money to equal the rate of return he promised. So when someone wanted to withdraw his principal and interest, Ponzi simply paid him from money received from new investors. Eventually he couldn't meet the demands for repayment, and his scheme collapsed. He ended up in jail. But another such scheme was started in 1935, and this one is still going. It's called Social Security. Social Security differs from a Ponzi scheme in only two ways: 1. The politicians won't arrest themselves. 2. The politicians can change the rules whenever necessary to keep the scheme going.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author compares Social Security to a Ponzi scheme, arguing it relies on new contributions to pay existing benefits and is sustained by political power rather than economic viability.
- In plain terms
- Social Security works like a scam where new money pays old debts, kept alive by politicians who control the rules.
- What can you take from it?
- Be aware that government programs may rely on unsustainable funding models protected by policy.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What makes a government program sustainable?
- How should risk be shared across generations?
Another view
The comparison overlooks that Social Security is a mandatory social insurance program with legal guarantees unlike a fraudulent private scheme.
More from Harry Browne
So what is government?... Very simply, it is an agency of coercion. Of course, there are other agencies of coercion -- such as the Mafia. So to be more precise…
Permalink to quote #22 Social Security is inherently unsound for the simple reason that it's a political program run by politicians for political purposes...Social Security operates …
Permalink to quote #24 Security... it's simply the recognition that changes will take place and the knowledge that you're willing to deal with whatever happens.
Permalink to quote #21
Related quotes
A national debt, if it is not excessive, will be to us a national blessing.
Alexander HamiltonAlexander Hamilton quote #1 The stock of money, prices and output was decidedly more unstable after the establishment of the Reserve System than before. The most dramatic period of instab…
Milton FriedmanMilton Friedman quote #14 Between 1999 and 2004 there was no investment in Australia, it all went into housing and consumption all borrowed on the current account. When Peter Costello r…
Paul KeatingPaul Keating quote #17