A French critic cleverly wrote that 'with Autumn Sonata Bergman does Bergman.' It is witty but unfortunate. For me, that is. I think it is only too true that Bergman (Ingmar, that is) did a Bergman... I love and admire the filmmaker Tarkovsky and believe him to be one of the greatest of all time. My admiration for Fellini is limitless. But I also feel that Tarkovsky began to make Tarkovsky films and that Fellini began to make Fellini films. Yet Kurosawa has never made a Kurosawa film. I have never been able to appreciate Bunuel. He discovered at an early stage that it is possible to fabricate ingenious tricks, which he elevated to a special kind of genius, particular to Bunuel, and then he repeated and varied his tricks. He always received applause. Bunuel nearly always made Bunuel films.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The speaker notes that many directors make films that are unmistakably their own style, while some, like Kurosawa, never produced a film that feels uniquely theirs.
- In plain terms
- Directors often create films that reflect their personal style, but not always.
- What can you take from it?
- Recognize the signature style of creators, but don’t assume it always emerges.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do you determine a director's unique voice?
- Can a filmmaker break their own style?
Another view
Not every director's work fits a single recognizable pattern.
More from Ingmar Bergman
If you have a faith, if you've some deep conviction, whether you're a Nazi or a Communist or what the hell else you are - then you can sacrifice yourself and o…
Permalink to quote #40 The Seventh Seal is one of the few films really close to my heart. Actually, I don't know why. It's certainly far from perfect. I had to contend with all sorts…
Permalink to quote #42 People think there's a solution... If everything is distributed in the proper quarters, put into the right pigeonholes, everything will be fine. But I'm not so…
Permalink to quote #39
Related quotes
I've always been skeptical of people who say they lose themselves in a part. Someone once came up to Spencer Tracy and asked, 'Aren't you tired of always playi…
James (Jimmy) StewartJames (Jimmy) Stewart quote #2 Bill is a good painter but he's a French painter.
Jackson PollockJackson Pollock quote #4 I think it would be so great if more people took up silk screening,so that no one would know whether my picture was mine or somebody else.
Andy WarholAndy Warhol quote #30