Skip to content
quotesby

History, like a vast river, propels logs, vegetation, rafts, and debris; it is full of live and dead things, some destined for resurrection; it mingles many waters and holds in solution invisible substances stolen from distant soils. Anything may become part of it; that is why it can be an image of the continuity of mankind. And it is also why some of its freight turns up again in the social sciences: they were constructed out of the contents of history in the same way as houses in medieval Rome were made out of stones taken from the Coliseum. But the special sciences based on sorted facts cannot be mistaken for rivers flowing in time and full of persons and events. They are systems fashioned with concepts, numbers, and abstract relations. For history, the reward of eluding method is to escape abstraction.

Jacques Barzun#11

SocietyCultureHistoryScienceAbstractionContinuityMethodologyResearch

About this quote

What does it mean?
History is a continuous flow containing all human activity, while social sciences extract sorted facts from it but lose the living context.
In plain terms
History is a living river of events, while science picks out specific facts and loses the human story.
What can you take from it?
History preserves the complexity of human experience better than abstract scientific methods.

Where it applies

  • analyzing historical trends
  • comparing science and history
  • understanding cultural change

Putting it to work

  • study history for context
  • avoid over-relying on statistics
  • value narrative in research

Questions to consider

  • How do we balance data with human stories?
  • Is abstraction necessary for progress?

Another view

The metaphor might oversimplify the value of structured scientific analysis.

More from Jacques Barzun

  1. We are accustomed to the artist scoundrel or specialist in vice, and unaccustomed to the creator in whom passion and reason and moral integrity hold in balance…

    Permalink to quote #10
  2. When plugged in, the least elaborate computer can be relied on to work to the fullest extent of its capacity. The greatest mind cannot be relied on for the sim…

    Permalink to quote #12
  3. The one thing that unifies men in a given age is not their individual philosophies but the dominant problem that these philosophies are designed to solve.

    Permalink to quote #9

Related quotes

  1. While the method of the natural sciences is... analytic, the method of the social sciences is better described as compositive or synthetic. It is the so-called…

    Friedrich HayekFriedrich Hayek quote #12
  2. Thus, we have three principles for increasing adequacy of data: if you must work with a single object, look for imperfections that record historical descent; i…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #30
  3. I am acutely aware of the fact that the marriage between mathematics and physics, which was so enormously fruitful in past centuries, has recently ended in div…

    Freeman DysonFreeman Dyson quote #1