Skip to content
quotesby

He never invested his whole moral capital in a man, a book, or a cause, but treasured up wisdom wherever it could be picked up, always with scrupulous acknowledgment ... His eclecticism saving him from the cycle of hope-disillusion-despair, his highest effectiveness was as a skirmisher in the daily battle for light and justice, as a critic of new doctrine and a refurbisher of old, as a voice of warning and encouragement. That his action has not been in vain, we can measure by how little Shaw's iconoclasm stirs our blood; we no longer remember what he destroyed that was blocking our view.

Jacques Barzun#29

Bernard shawCriticismEffectivenessImpactOpen mindednessSuccessWisdom

About this quote

What does it mean?
Shaw did not tie his worth to specific causes but collected wisdom everywhere, acting as a critic and guide whose success is shown by how little we notice the obstacles he removed.
In plain terms
Shaw stayed open to wisdom everywhere instead of blindly following one cause, and his success is shown because we don't even notice the bad ideas he stopped.
What can you take from it?
True effectiveness often comes from staying open and critical rather than rigidly loyal to one idea.

Where it applies

  • evaluating ideas
  • navigating debates
  • building wisdom

Putting it to work

  • stay open-minded
  • critique respectfully
  • value subtle impact

Questions to consider

  • How do you measure someone's real impact?
  • Is it better to be a specialist or generalist?

Another view

Being too eclectic might prevent deep commitment to a specific cause.

More from Jacques Barzun

  1. Like Nietzsche, he rails at romanticism, but it is evident that what they both mean by the word is the cliches of second-hand romance. Historic romanticism is …

    Permalink to quote #28
  2. For Shaw as for Goethe, the obligation to strive is a primary feeling: reason initiates nothing and would stop everything. Its use is to come after the fact an…

    Permalink to quote #30
  3. No one has ever used historical examples, near or remote, with the detail, precision, and directness to be found in every page of Shaw.

    Permalink to quote #27

Related quotes

  1. In the case of any person whose judgment is really deserving of confidence, how has it become so? Because he has kept his mind open to criticism of his opinion…

    John Stuart MillJohn Stuart Mill quote #27
  2. He never invested his whole moral capital in a man, a book, or a cause, but treasured up wisdom wherever it could be picked up, always with scrupulous acknowle…

    George Bernard ShawGeorge Bernard Shaw quote #251
  3. Si hubiera estado presente en la Creacion, habria dado algunas indicaciones utiles.

    Alfonso X of CastileAlfonso X of Castile quote #1