The composer does not want the self-sufficiency of a richly complex text: he or she wants to feel that the text is something in need of musical setting.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Composers prefer texts that invite musical setting rather than those that are already complete and self-sufficient.
- In plain terms
- Musicians want words that need music to feel complete.
- What can you take from it?
- Collaboration requires room for input.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What makes a text open to music?
- How do you collaborate across mediums?
Another view
Some composers enjoy setting dense, self-contained texts.
More from James Fenton
Can the ear hear a thirteen-syllable line as consisting of thirteen syllables? I don't think so, but I think that a series of thirteen-syllable lines (supposin…
Permalink to quote #12 My sonnet asserts that the sonnet still lives. My epic, should such fortune befall me, asserts that the heroic narrative is not lost - that it is born again, p…
Permalink to quote #14 It normally happens that if you put two words together, or two syllables together, one of them will attract more weight, more emphasis, than the other. In othe…
Permalink to quote #11
Related quotes
Bon Dieu; la voila terminee, cette pauvre petite messe. Est-ce bien de la musique sacree que je viens de faire, ou bien de la sacre musique ? J'etais ne pour l…
Gioachino RossiniGioachino Rossini quote #2 In The Doors we have both musicians and poets, and both know of each other's art, so we can effect a synthesis. In the case of Tim Buckley or Dylan you have on…
Robbie KriegerRobbie Krieger quote #3 Basically, I write from a two person standpoint. First, I let the song take hold and I put down the idea as a raw emotional statement. Then I let it breathe an…
Bradley JosephBradley Joseph quote #3