In the interior of the atom, Bohr had tried the plan of retaining the particle-electron and modifying the classical mechanics. Heisenberg took the opposite course, his procedure amounting in effect to retaining the classical mechanics, at least in form, and modifying the electron. Actually, the electron dropped out all together, because it exists only as a matter of inference and not of direct observation. For the same reason, the new theory contains no mention of atoms, nuclei, protons, or of electricity in any shape or form. The existences of all these are matters of inference, and Heisenberg's purely mathematical theory could no more make contact with them than with the efficiency of a turbine or with the price of wheat.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Heisenberg removed direct reference to particles and atoms from his theory, keeping only mathematical inferences.
- In plain terms
- The new theory does not talk about electrons or atoms directly, only about what we infer.
- What can you take from it?
- Scientific theories may drop direct references to objects if they are inferred.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Does a theory need to describe reality directly?
- What exists if we can only infer it?
Another view
This view rejects direct talk of particles which conflicts with everyday scientific language.
More from James Jeans
A similar situation occurred in astronomy, where the Newtonian law of gravitation had been found to predict the orbits of the outer planets with great accuracy…
Permalink to quote #33 The main result reached by the new theory was that the classical mechanics can be made to account for the whole range of spectral phenomena, provided entirely …
Permalink to quote #35 Bohr had... discovered that the frequencies corresponding to very large integers could be calculated accurately from the classical mechanics; they were simply …
Permalink to quote #32
Related quotes
Light and matter are both single entities, and the apparent duality arises in the limitations of our language. It is not surprising that our language should be…
Werner HeisenbergWerner Heisenberg quote #2 It seems that if one is working from the point of view of getting beauty in one's equations, and if one has really a sound insight, one is on a sure line of pr…
Paul DiracPaul Dirac quote #3 The quantum theory of parallel universes is not the problem, it is the solution. It is not some troublesome, optional interpretation emerging from arcane theor…
David DeutschDavid Deutsch quote #5