Skip to content
quotesby

If his 'magna imago' could return to earth, he would be puzzled at some of our experiments in empire, and might well complain that the imperfections of his work were taken as its virtues, and that so many truths had gone silently out of mind. He had prided himself on having given the world peace, and he would be amazed by the loud praise of war as a natural and wholesome concomitant of a nation's life. Wars he had fought from an anxious desire to safeguard his people, as the shepherd builds the defences of his sheepfold; but he hated the thing, because he knew well the deadly 'disordering,' which the Greek historian noted as the consequence of the most triumphant campaign. He would marvel, too, at the current talk of racial purity, the exaltation of one breed of men as the chosen favourites of the gods. That would seem to him not only a defiance of the new Christian creed, but of the Stoicism which he had sincerely professed.

John Buchan#62

HistoryWarEmpireLegacy

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author critiques modern views on empire, war, and racial purity by imagining how a historical ruler would react. He notes the irony of glorifying war when it causes disorder.
In plain terms
An ancient ruler would hate modern war and racial ideas.
What can you take from it?
History often distorts the true intentions of past leaders.

Where it applies

  • historical analysis
  • political commentary

Putting it to work

  • reassess historical legacies
  • critique modern imperialism

Questions to consider

  • Would past leaders approve of how we use their legacy?
  • Is war truly a wholesome part of life?

Another view

It romanticizes the intentions of historical conquerors.

More from John Buchan

  1. History does not repeat itself except with variations, and it is idle to look for exact parallels, but we can trace a resemblance between the conditions of his…

    Permalink to quote #61
  2. The Augustan constitution remains one of the major products of the human intelligence. It was a whole into which the parts fitted smoothly, but both whole and …

    Permalink to quote #63
  3. They want to hurry things quicker than the Almighty means them to go. I don't altogether blame them either, for I'm mortally impatient myself. But it s no good…

    Permalink to quote #60

Related quotes

  1. At present, I am a poet trying to be a soldier. To tell the truth, I am not interested in writing nowadays, except in so far as writing is the expression of so…

    Joyce KilmerJoyce Kilmer quote #1
  2. Our great-grand-children, when they learn how we began this war by snatching glory out of defeat, and then swept on to victory, may also learn how the little h…

    J. B. PriestleyJ. B. Priestley quote #2
  3. And thus He mused: 'From here, indeed Shall we strike terror in the Swede? And here a city by our labor Founded, shall gall our haughty neighbor; 'Here cut' - …

    Aleksandr PushkinAleksandr Pushkin quote #3