I recommended that we establish contact with [the Chinese communists]. We had established contact through a military mission there but that we did not ... we should not withdraw recognition from Chiang Kai-shek at that time, but we should recognize the inevitability of the loss, Chiang's loss to Mao, and that therefore we should, establish relations of the type that I described that we had with warlords, with the communists, and that we have, say, a consulate there, so that there was a political contact in addition to the military. That, of course, did not go down.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Davies advised establishing pragmatic diplomatic relations with Chinese communists rather than maintaining ties only with Chiang.
- In plain terms
- He suggested making contact with communist leaders despite not recognizing them officially.
- What can you take from it?
- Pragmatism in politics requires acknowledging changing realities.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do nations balance idealism and pragmatism?
- When is recognition of rivals necessary?
Another view
The quote lacks context on which officials received this advice or why it was rejected.
More from John P. Davies
I have known a great number of men.... I have known none who seemed more the whole man, none more finished a civilized product in all a man should be - in mode…
Permalink to quote #2 The crime he did commit was that of practical, complicated, and nuanced thought. Though an ardent anti-communist, he also knew that Chiang's regime was bankrup…
Permalink to quote #3 Going back to Davies, at the time after the war that Davies was a member of the policy staff of the State Department, he had advised (this was under Dulles), t…
Permalink to quote #4
Related quotes
The crime he did commit was that of practical, complicated, and nuanced thought. Though an ardent anti-communist, he also knew that Chiang's regime was bankrup…
John P. DaviesJohn P. Davies quote #3 Foreign Policy is not missionary work.
Henry KissingerHenry Kissinger quote #22 America betrays its friends. It sets them up and betrays them. I'd rather be America's enemy.
Ahmed ChalabiAhmed Chalabi quote #1