On June 22nd, [1633,] in the morning, in the great hall of the Convent of Santa Maria Sopra Minerva, Galileo was found guilty of holding a false doctrine. He went down on his knees and both abjured and condemned his own errors. He swore never to argue such doctrines again. It was thus definitely confirmed that the sun did rotate around the earth...Santa Maria Sopra Minerva. Saint Mary Over Minerva. Power over wisdom.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Galileo’s trial shows institutional power suppressing science.
- In plain terms
- Galileo was forced to deny science to please the church.
- What can you take from it?
- Institutions can override truth with authority.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How does power affect knowledge?
- Who decides truth?
Another view
Historical context involves complex theological arguments.
More from John Ralston Saul
Venereal: From Venus, the goddess of love, this word refers to the reality of desire. With the rise of Protestantism and science, the word 'disease' was tacked…
Permalink to quote #45 There is something silly about grown men and women striving to reduce their vision of themselves and of civilization to bean counting.
Permalink to quote #47 United States: .... A nation given either to unjustified over-enthusiasms or infantile furies.
Permalink to quote #44
Related quotes
Such are the scientific justifications of the principle of coercion. They are not merely weak but absolutely invalid, yet they are so much needed by those who …
Leo TolstoyLeo Tolstoy quote #89 Ces deux moities de Dieu, le pape et l'empereur!
Victor HugoVictor Hugo quote #1 My so-called foreign friends do neither me nor the situation nor themselves any good when they try to bring me into opposition to the allegedly impossible Nati…
Hjalmar SchachtHjalmar Schacht quote #1