Skip to content
quotesby

While the founding fathers agonized over the question 'particle' or 'wave', de Broglie in 1925 proposed the obvious answer 'particle' and 'wave'. Is it not clear from the smallness of the scintillation on the screen that we have to do with a particle? And is it not clear, from the diffraction and interference patterns, that the motion of the particle is directed by a wave? De Broglie showed in detail how the motion of a particle, passing through just one of two holes in screen, could be influenced by waves propagating through both holes. And so influenced that the particle does not go where the waves cancel out, but is attracted to where they cooperate. This idea seems to me so natural and simple, to resolve the wave-particle dilemma in such a clear and ordinary way, that it is a great mystery to me that it was so generally ignored.

John Stewart Bell#3

PhysicsHistoryScience

About this quote

What does it mean?
Bell praises de Broglie's particle-wave guidance idea as natural and simple, questioning why it was ignored.
In plain terms
De Broglie's idea that waves guide particles is simple and natural but was ignored.
What can you take from it?
Simple solutions to paradoxes can be overlooked.

Where it applies

  • physics history
  • scientific community
  • theory development

Putting it to work

  • reconsider ignored theories
  • value simplicity in solutions

Questions to consider

  • Why do good ideas get ignored?
  • Is simplicity always valid?

Another view

The idea may have practical limitations Bell doesn't address.

More from John Stewart Bell

  1. The concept of 'measurement' becomes so fuzzy on reflection that it is quite surprising to have it appearing in physical theory at the most fundamental level..…

    Permalink to quote #2
  2. Is it not good to know what follows from what, even if it is not necessarily FAPP? [FAPP is Bell's suggested abbreviation of 'for all practical purposes.'] Sup…

    Permalink to quote #4
  3. Theoretical physicists live in a classical world, looking out into a quantum-mechanical world. The latter we describe only subjectively, in terms of procedures…

    Permalink to quote #1

Related quotes

  1. Although the problem of transmuting chemical elements into each other is much older than a satisfactory definition of the very concept of chemical element, it …

    Enrico FermiEnrico Fermi quote #1
  2. I am acutely aware of the fact that the marriage between mathematics and physics, which was so enormously fruitful in past centuries, has recently ended in div…

    Freeman DysonFreeman Dyson quote #1
  3. I came into the room which was half-dark and presently spotted Lord Kelvin in the audience, and realised that I was in for trouble at the last part of my speec…

    Ernest RutherfordErnest Rutherford quote #3