Here's a story: There was a documentary filmmaker who was making a documentary film about education in America. And he's shooting across this classroom with lots of people, kids, who are completely distracted at the television in the back of the classroom. When they get back to the editing room, they realize that on the television, you can barely make out the show for two seconds; it's 'The Simpsons,' Homer Simpson on the screen. So they call up Matt Groening, who was a friend of the documentary filmmaker, and say, you know, Is this going to be a problem? It's only a couple seconds. Matt says, No, no, no, it's not going to be a problem, call so and so. So they called so and so, and so and so said call so and so. Eventually, the so and so turns out to be the lawyers, so when they got to the lawyers, they said, Is this going to be a problem? It's a documentary film. It's about education. It's a couple seconds. The so and so said 25,000 bucks. 25,000 bucks?! It's a couple seconds! What do you mean 25,000 bucks? The so and so said, I don't give a goddamn what it is for. $25,000 bucks or change your movie. Now you look at this and you say this is insane. It's insane. And if it is only Hollywood that has to deal with this, OK, that's fine. Let them be insane. The problem is their insane rules are now being applied to the whole world. This insanity of control is expanding as everything you do touches copyrights.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- A documentary filmmaker faced legal hurdles even for a brief, incidental clip of a TV show due to complex copyright clearance chains.
- In plain terms
- Even using a short TV clip in a documentary led to endless lawyer referrals and clearance issues.
- What can you take from it?
- Copyright clearance can be overly complex even for minor, educational uses.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How hard is it to clear rights for small clips?
- Does copyright hinder education?
Another view
The story is anecdotal and may not reflect all legal outcomes.
More from Lawrence Lessig
Now, here's the thing you've got to remember. You've got to see this. This is the point. (And Jack Valenti misses this.) Here's the point: Never has it been mo…
Permalink to quote #25 It's insane. It's extreme. It's controlled by political interests. It has no justification in the traditional values that justify legal regulation. And we've d…
Permalink to quote #27 Here's a simple copyright lesson: Law regulates copies. What's that mean? Well, before the Internet, think of this as a world of all possible uses of a copyrig…
Permalink to quote #24
Related quotes
Here's a simple copyright lesson: Law regulates copies. What's that mean? Well, before the Internet, think of this as a world of all possible uses of a copyrig…
Lawrence LessigLawrence Lessig quote #24 Fair use is not in the law.
Jack ValentiJack Valenti quote #30 In university they don't tell you that the greater part of the law is learning to tolerate fools.
Doris LessingDoris Lessing quote #2