There is no necessary connection between the important events of a life and the records of it that have been preserved in memory, in documents, in memorials, or in living testimony. The biographer must compose his life of what he has, just as the archeologist must restore his temple or his statue with such fragments as thieving time and careless men have left him; but fate often ironically leaves him a well-preserved leg and a dismembered torso, while the head, which would supply the main clue to the body, is missing. Hence, in addition to the purposive selection exercised by the subject himself and by the biographer in making use of such materials as are left, there exists a purely external selection dominated by chance, which cuts across the evidence in an arbitrary fashion. To correct for such distortions the biographer must be an anatomist of character: he must be able to restore the missing nose in plaster, even if he does not find the original marble.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Historical records often miss key parts of a life, so biographers must reconstruct character from fragments and chance survivals.
- In plain terms
- Life records are incomplete, so writers must guess the missing parts.
- What can you take from it?
- Understand that history is fragmentary and requires interpretation.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What parts of history are missing?
- How do you judge a life?
Another view
Some lives are better documented than others.
More from Lewis Mumford
Each religion is a brave guess at the authorship of Hamlet. Yet, as far as the play goes does it make any difference whether Shakespeare or Bacon wrote it? Wou…
Permalink to quote #38 Forget the damned motor car and build the cities for lovers and friends.
Permalink to quote #40 The relation between psyche and soma, mind and brain, are peculiarly intimate; but, as in marriage, the partners are not inseparable: indeed their divorce was …
Permalink to quote #37
Related quotes
'Det finns ingenting som inte hant, men mycket som inte berattats.'
Fritiof Nilsson PiratenFritiof Nilsson Piraten quote #2 A man's memory is bound to be a distortion of his past in accordance with his present interests, and the most faithful autobiography is likely to mirror less w…
Fawn BrodieFawn Brodie quote #3 People don't forget, do they?
Rudolf HessRudolf Hess quote #5