Skip to content
quotesby

Despite the propaganda, there are no monsters, or none that can be finally buried. Finish one off, and circumstances and the radio create another. Believe me: whole armies have prayed fervently to God all night and meant it, and been slaughtered anyway. Brutality wins frequently, and large outcomes have turned on the invention of a mechanical device, viz. radar. True, valour sometimes counts for something, as at Thermopylae. Sometimes being right - though ultimate virtue, by agreed tradition, is decided by the winner. Sometimes men throw themselves on grenades and burst like paper bags of guts to save their comrades. I can admire that. But rats and cholera have won many wars. Those, and potatoes, or the absence of them.

Margaret Atwood#32

HistoryWarChanceFateHeroism

About this quote

What does it mean?
War is often decided by chance or disease rather than heroism or rightness.
In plain terms
Armies pray and fight but disease and random events often decide who wins.
What can you take from it?
Recognize that luck and chance often decide wars.

Where it applies

  • discussions on war
  • historical analysis
  • strategy

Putting it to work

  • consider random factors
  • avoid glorification

Questions to consider

  • What really wins wars?
  • Do we overvalue courage?

Another view

Sometimes strategy and virtue do matter in outcomes.

More from Margaret Atwood

  1. Instead of this, I tell what I hope will pass as truth. A blunt thing, not lovely. The truth is seldom welcome, especially at dinner, though I am good at what …

    Permalink to quote #31
  2. In the interests of research I have walked on many battlefields that once were liquid with pulped men's bodies and spangled with exploded shells and splayed bo…

    Permalink to quote #33
  3. In general I might agree with you: women should not contemplate war, should not weigh tactics impartially, or evade the word enemy, or view both sides and deno…

    Permalink to quote #30

Related quotes

  1. Death by hanging...I deserved it and I expected it, as I've always told you. I am glad that I have had the chance to defend myself and to think things over in …

    Hans FrankHans Frank quote #2
  2. Can anyone alter fate? All of us combined...or one great figure...or someone strategically placed, who happens to be in the right spot. Chance. Accident. And o…

    Philip Kindred DickPhilip Kindred Dick quote #17
  3. If Paulus's army had capitulated before the end, the Russians would have had the advantage of withdrawing forces against Paulus and against the southern front,…

    Erich von MansteinErich von Manstein quote #1