Skip to content
quotesby

However, there are all sorts of behaviours in the Bible that might be called mad now, but aren't designated as insanity by the text itself. People see visions - of angels going up and down ladders, of fiery chariots - and, like Moses, who hears a bush talking, and Balaam the prophet who has a conversation with his donkey, they hear voices of those who cannot be said to be present in any usual sense of the word. They also speak in tongues, as the disciples do at Pentecost. Like madness, the visions, the voices and the speaking in tongues are due to external and usually divine agencies. In a world so permeated with supernatural powers, there are no accidents, and in one so riddled with prophets - who went into a frenzy while prophesying - many more kinds of behaviour were accepted as normal, at least for a prophet or an inspired person, than would be the case now. John the Baptist, dressed in animal skins and wandering around in the wilderness denouncing his social superiors, was not thought of as a de-institutionalized street person who's gone off his medications, but as a saint. And this was the pattern for mediaeval views of aberrant behaviour - if you were acting crazy it was a divine punishment, or else you were possessed, by powers either divine or demonic - perhaps aided, in the latter case, by witches.

Margaret Atwood#51

CultureReligionBibleExperienceMedicineSpirituality

About this quote

What does it mean?
Atwood contrasts modern medical views with biblical contexts where strange behaviors were seen as divine experiences rather than madness.
In plain terms
In biblical times, visions and voices were often seen as gifts from God rather than signs of illness.
What can you take from it?
Context determines whether unusual behavior is seen as spiritual or medical.

Where it applies

  • comparing worldviews
  • interpreting religious texts
  • understanding cultural contexts

Putting it to work

  • distinguish context in interpretation
  • study religious experiences
  • analyze belief impacts

Questions to consider

  • How do we judge strange experiences?
  • What defines normal vs mad?

Another view

Modern medicine also acknowledges cultural and spiritual factors in mental health diagnosis.

More from Margaret Atwood

  1. For a thousand years, the Bible was almost the only book people read, if they could read at all. The stories that were officially told and portrayed were Bibli…

    Permalink to quote #50
  2. What Elizabethan playwrights learned from the Greek classics was not theories of insanity, but dramatic practice - that is, madness is a dandy theatrical eleme…

    Permalink to quote #52
  3. For every age there is a popular idea about what madness is, what causes it, and how a mad person should look and behave; and it's usually these popular ideas,…

    Permalink to quote #49

Related quotes

  1. The human organism itself seems to be hardwired for these deep spiritual patterns, although not necessarily for the specific ways that they show up in a partic…

    Ken WilberKen Wilber quote #29
  2. Oh, come on. Revelation was a mushroom dream that belonged in the Apocrypha. The New Testament is basically about what happened when God got religion

    Terry PratchettTerry Pratchett quote #23
  3. Religion, therefore, as I now ask you arbitrarily to take it, shall mean for us the feelings, acts, and experiences of individual men in their solitude, so far…

    William JamesWilliam James quote #52