Skip to content
quotesby

Using the moral yardstick mentioned by [Moshe Sharett], I must ask: Are [we justified] in opening fire on the Arabs who cross [the border] to reap the crops they planted in our territory; they, their women, and their children? Will this stand up to moral scrutiny . . .? We shoot at those from among the 200,000 hungry arabs who cross the line - will this stand up to moral review? Arabs cross to collect the grain that they left in the abandoned villages and we set mines for them and they go back without an arm or a leg. . . [It may be that this] cannot pass review, but I know no other method of guarding the borders. then tomorrow the State of Israel will have no borders.

Moshe Dayan#7

WarEthicsMoralityPolicySecurity

About this quote

What does it mean?
Dayan questions the morality of shooting Arabs who cross to harvest crops, acknowledging the action may not pass moral review but claiming no alternative to border security.
In plain terms
He doubts the moral rightness of lethal force but sees no other option.
What can you take from it?
Security dilemmas often force morally ambiguous choices.

Where it applies

  • immigration control
  • resource scarcity
  • military engagement

Putting it to work

  • non‑lethal deterrents
  • humanitarian corridors

Questions to consider

  • Can security be achieved without lethal force?
  • How should moral scrutiny shape policy?

Another view

The justification may ignore proportionality and civilian harm.

More from Moshe Dayan

  1. The quote is taken from an address Dayan gave to Technion University students on March 19, 1969. A transcription of the speech appeared in Ha'aretz on April 4,…

    Permalink to quote #6
  2. The only method that proved effective, not justified or moral but effective, when Arabs plant mines on our side [is retaliation]. If we try to search for the […

    Permalink to quote #8
  3. We have no solution, you shall continue to live like dogs, and whoever wishes may leave, and we will see where this process leads.

    Permalink to quote #5

Related quotes

  1. 'I think in this case international law stood in the way of doing the right thing.' (2003)

    Richard PerleRichard Perle quote #2
  2. I am not proud of the part I played in it. I did it because it was necessary for the safety of this country. That's why I am such a great exponent of stopping …

    Hyman G. RickoverHyman G. Rickover quote #2
  3. Finally, there is a compelling moral argument against war in Iraq. Military force is justified only in self-defense; naked aggression is the province of dictat…

    Ron PaulRon Paul quote #28