Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Catholics are depicted as seeing personhood in anything that can talk. This suggests an inclusive or perhaps uncritical view of baptism.
In plain terms
Catholics will baptize anything that can talk as a person.
What can you take from it?
Personhood may be granted based on communication ability.

Where it applies

  • religious studies
  • animal rights
  • AI ethics

Putting it to work

  • consider criteria for personhood
  • explore faith boundaries

Questions to consider

  • What makes something a person?
  • How does faith change definitions?

Another view

Not all traditions agree that speech equals personhood.

More from Orson Scott Card

  1. I don't believe that there are aliens. I believe there are really different people.

    Permalink to quote #1033
  2. We're still struggling to find a significant amount of intelligence here, so no.

    Permalink to quote #1035
  3. No child can be understood without knowing the parents; no revolution can be understood without knowing the ancient regime; no colony can be understood without…

    Permalink to quote #1032

Related quotes

  1. Some people think that all the equipment you need to discuss religion is a mouth.

    Herman WoukHerman Wouk quote #11
  2. My chief request is that anyone who is a servant of God be ready and willing, to carry this letter forward; may it never be hidden or stolen by anyone, but rat…

    Saint PatrickSaint Patrick quote #11
  3. Je suis esclave de mon bapteme.

    Arthur RimbaudArthur Rimbaud quote #19