If I had taken away the desire for violence then humanity would not have been humanity. Not that human beings need to be violent in order to be human, but if you ever lose the will to control, the will to destroy, then it must be because you choose to lose it. My role was not to force you to be gentle and kind; it was to keep you alive while you decided for yourselves what kind of people you wanted to be.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Violence is part of human choice; forcing gentleness removes agency and growth.
- In plain terms
- You must choose to be peaceful, or you cannot truly be human.
- What can you take from it?
- Peace requires personal choice, not external enforcement.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can moral growth happen without the ability to do harm?
- What defines being human?
Another view
Some people may never choose peace without external constraints.
More from Orson Scott Card
Wouldn't it have been better to change humanity so it no longer desired to destroy itself?
Permalink to quote #328 He saw them with such better understanding that they took on power and meaning beyond anything in his experience before.
Permalink to quote #330 I will not be tamed, only persuaded. I will not be coerced or led blindly or tricked or bullied - I am willing only to be convinced. If you don't trust your ow…
Permalink to quote #327
Related quotes
Wouldn't it have been better to change humanity so it no longer desired to destroy itself?
Orson Scott CardOrson Scott Card quote #328 There is no flag large enough to cover the shame of killing innocent people for a purpose which is unattainable.
Howard ZinnHoward Zinn quote #3 I have never believed in war. It is a crime against humanity whether you win or lose. I just read an article in this magazine I have in my hands that one day t…
Hjalmar SchachtHjalmar Schacht quote #9