Skip to content
quotesby

Humans had to evolve what no other primate had: a sense of identity with a group so powerful that it could swallow up the individual identity, at least to a large degree. Humans couldn't have the deep, self-sacrificing loyalty to more than one or two communities at a time. Thus communities were inevitably in conflict with each other, competing for the loyalty of their members. The tribe had to break down the solidarity of the family; religion had to compete with nation for loyalty. But once a community had that loyalty, the most ardent members would gladly die for it. Not for the other individuals directly, but for the interests of the group as a whole, because in the human mind, that group was the self, and the individual was able to regard himself as merely one iteration of the pattern of the whole

Orson Scott Card#450

IdentityWarLoyaltyEvolution

About this quote

What does it mean?
Humans evolved group loyalty that supersedes individual identity, leading to conflict between groups.
In plain terms
Loyalty to a group makes people act as one and fight others.
What can you take from it?
Group identity can override personal identity.

Where it applies

  • nationalism
  • religious conflict
  • team dynamics

Putting it to work

  • manage group loyalties

Questions to consider

  • What groups define you?
  • When does loyalty become harmful?

Another view

It generalizes complex social evolution.

More from Orson Scott Card

  1. Humans feel compassion primarily for those they conceive of as being part of themselves

    Permalink to quote #449
  2. Humans, in order to rise above the animals, had learned how to convert themselves into nothing more than organs or limbs or even disposable fingernails and hai…

    Permalink to quote #451
  3. I'll be dead and you'll think about this day and wonder which of us was more the slave, you or me!

    Permalink to quote #448

Related quotes

  1. They called themselves the Munrungs. It meant The People, or The True Human Beings. It's what most people call themselves, to begin with. And then one day the …

    Terry PratchettTerry Pratchett quote #55
  2. We came for murder, pullin' up in a herse/Westside was the war cry bustin' all freely screaming fuck all ya'll niggas in Swahili

    Tupac ShakurTupac Shakur quote #60
  3. Last night I was east with them And west within Trying to be for you what you wanna see.

    Ben FoldsBen Folds quote #1