God is a model through which the excellence of man is to be estimated, whilst the abstract perfection of the human character is the type of the actual perfection of the divine. It is not to be believed that a person of such comprehensive views as Jesus Christ could have fallen into so manifest a contradiction as to assert that men would be tortured after death by that Being whose character is held up as a model to human kind, because he is incapable of malevolence and revenge. All the arguments which have been brought forward to justify retribution fail, when retribution is destined neither to operate as an example to other agents, nor to the offender himself. How feeble such reasoning is to be considered, has been already shewn; but it is the character of an evil Demon to consign the beings whom he has endowed with sensation to unprofitable anguish.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Shelley argues that if God is a model for human excellence, He cannot be malevolent. Therefore, the idea of eternal punishment contradicts the divine character and is unjust.
- In plain terms
- A perfect being cannot logically punish people forever for that would contradict His goodness.
- What can you take from it?
- Reject religious ideas that contradict moral logic and divine nature.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Does a good God logically punish forever?
- Can divine nature contradict human ethics?
Another view
The argument assumes a specific definition of divinity that not all faiths share.
More from Percy Bysshe Shelley
The conceptions which any nation or individual entertains of the God of its popular worship may be inferred from their own actions and opinions, which are the …
Permalink to quote #194 Jesus Christ represented God as the principle of all good, the source of all happiness, the wise and benevolent Creator and Preserver of all living things. But…
Permalink to quote #196 Mankind, transmitting from generation to generation the legacy of accumulated vengeances, and pursuing with the feelings of duty the misery of their fellow-bei…
Permalink to quote #193
Related quotes
A God all mercy is a God unjust.
Edward YoungEdward Young quote #52 Dieu serait injuste si nous n'etions pas coupables.
Charles BaudelaireCharles Baudelaire quote #64 Like some magistrate grown gray in office, Calmly he contemplates alike the just And unjust, with indifference he notes Evil and good, and knows not wrath nor …
Aleksandr PushkinAleksandr Pushkin quote #19