Skip to content
quotesby

Some benefit has not failed to flow from the imperfect attempts which have been made to erect a system of equal rights to property and power upon the basis of arbitrary institutions. They have undoubtedly, in every case, from the instability of their foundation, failed. Still, they constitute a record of those epochs at which a trite sense of justice suggested itself to the understandings of men, so that they consented to forego all the cherished delights of luxury, all the habitual gratifications arising out of the possession or the expectation of power, all the superstitions with which the accumulated authority of ages had made them dear and venerable. They are so many trophies erected in the enemy's land, to mark the limits of the victorious progress of truth and justice.

Percy Bysshe Shelley#212

SocietyHistoryJusticeProgressReform

About this quote

What does it mean?
Even failed attempts at creating equal rights show that justice matters, marking progress even if they ultimately collapse.
In plain terms
Failed movements for equality still prove that people value justice.
What can you take from it?
Failed reforms still mark progress toward truth and justice.

Where it applies

  • historical analysis of reform
  • social movement planning
  • political theory

Putting it to work

  • study past failed reforms
  • document social movements
  • build on historical lessons

Questions to consider

  • Does failure in reform still count as progress?
  • How do we learn from unstable political foundations?

Another view

The quote romanticizes failure as trophies which may overlook the real suffering caused by unstable systems.

More from Percy Bysshe Shelley

  1. Every man, in proportion to his virtue, considers himself, with respect to the great community of mankind, as the steward and guardian of their interests in th…

    Permalink to quote #211
  2. No mistake is more to be deplored than the conception that a system of morals and religion should derive any portion of its authority either from the circumsta…

    Permalink to quote #213
  3. The demagogues of the infant republic of the Christian sect, attaining through eloquence or artifice, to influence amongst its members, first violated (under t…

    Permalink to quote #210

Related quotes

  1. Let us speak of our madness. We are always being called mad. If we are mad - we and our brothers in America who are walking hand in hand with us in the vanguar…

    Edith SitwellEdith Sitwell quote #1
  2. First silence. Then denial. Then support of the insupportable. Then vilification of the dissenters. The pattern is as old as time.

    Andrew SullivanAndrew Sullivan quote #3
  3. Expositions are the timekeepers of progress.

    William McKinleyWilliam McKinley quote #3