Skip to content
quotesby

I do not say, and I do not believe, that Christians are as bad as their creeds. In spite of church and dogma, there have been millions and millions of men and women true to the loftiest and most generous promptings of the human heart. They have been true to their convictions, and, with a self-denial and fortitude excelled by none, have labored and suffered for the salvation of men. Imbued with the spirit of self-sacrifice, believing that by personal effort they could rescue at least a few souls from the infinite shadow of hell, they have cheerfully endured every hardship and scorned every danger. And yet, notwithstanding all this, they believed that honest error was a crime. They knew that the Bible so declared, and they believed that all unbelievers would be eternally lost. They believed that religion was of God, and all heresy of the devil. They killed heretics in defence of their own souls and the souls of their children. They killed them because, according to their idea, they were the enemies of God, and because the Bible teaches that the blood of the unbeliever is a most acceptable sacrifice to heaven.

Robert G. Ingersoll#29

FaithMoralityChristianityIntolerance

About this quote

What does it mean?
Ingersoll acknowledges that while Christians are often good people, their beliefs lead them to view honest error as a crime worthy of eternal punishment or death.
In plain terms
Christians are often kind and self-sacrificing, yet they believe honest mistakes are crimes and kill those who disagree.
What can you take from it?
Good people can support harmful doctrines that punish honest disagreement.

Where it applies

  • debating religious ethics
  • analyzing religious violence
  • distinguishing belief from behavior

Putting it to work

  • promoting tolerance
  • questioning dogma
  • advocating for free thought

Questions to consider

  • Can someone be good but believe harmful things?
  • How do we separate belief from conduct?

Another view

It risks equating belief with action too closely.

More from Robert G. Ingersoll

  1. According to the theologians, God, the Father of us all, wrote a letter to his children. The children have always differed somewhat as to the meaning of this l…

    Permalink to quote #28
  2. Nature never prompted a loving mother to throw her child into the Ganges. Nature never prompted men to exterminate each other for a difference of opinion conce…

    Permalink to quote #30
  3. Every church pretends that it has a revelation from God, and that this revelation must be given to the people through the church; that the church acts through …

    Permalink to quote #27

Related quotes

  1. There are hundreds of millions who believe the Messiah has come. If he did, then it is unfortunately the case that his heroic sacrifice and death have had no e…

    Steve AllenSteve Allen quote #7
  2. As to Jesus of Nazareth, my Opinion of whom you particularly desire, I think the System of Morals and his Religion, as he left them to us, the best the world e…

    Benjamin FranklinBenjamin Franklin quote #25
  3. To the corruptions of Christianity I am indeed opposed; but not to the genuine precepts of Jesus himself. I am a Christian, in the only sense he wished any one…

    Thomas JeffersonThomas Jefferson quote #43