Skip to content
quotesby

In his attempt to unite the Good and the True by making the Good the highest Idea of all, Plato is nevertheless usurping arete's place with dialectically determined truth. Once the Good has been contained as a dialectical idea it is no trouble for another philosopher to come along and show by dialectical methods that arete, the Good, can be more advantageously demoted to a lower position within a 'true' order of things, more compatible with the inner workings of dialectic. Such a philosopher was not long in coming. His name was Aristotle.

Robert M. Pirsig#58

PhilosophyHistoryAristotlePlatoIdeas

About this quote

What does it mean?
Plato’s unification of Good and True made the Good a dialectical idea, allowing later philosophers like Aristotle to demote it within a new order of truth.
In plain terms
Plato’s hierarchy enabled Aristotle to rearrange the place of the Good.
What can you take from it?
Ideas evolve as later thinkers reinterpret them.

Where it applies

  • historical analysis
  • theoretical development

Putting it to work

  • study philosophical lineage
  • compare frameworks

Questions to consider

  • What drives the re‑ordering of ideas?
  • How does dialectics shape truth?

Another view

May overstate Aristotle’s intent as merely demoting Plato’s Good.

More from Robert M. Pirsig

  1. Plato finds it necessary to separate, for example, 'horseness' from 'horse' and say that horseness is real and fixed and true and unmoving, while the horse is …

    Permalink to quote #57
  2. Under Aristotle the 'Reader,' whose knowledge of Trojan arete seems conspicuously absent, forms and substances dominate all. The Good is a relatively minor bra…

    Permalink to quote #59
  3. The Good was not a form of reality. It was reality itself, ever changing, ultimately unknowable in any kind of fixed, rigid way.

    Permalink to quote #56

Related quotes

  1. As formas superiores do pensamento tem uma tendencia fatal a tornar-se na futura lei revelada: e toda a filosofia termina, nos seus velhos dias, por ser religi…

    Jose Maria Eca de QueirozJose Maria Eca de Queiroz quote #6
  2. One cannot conceive anything so strange and so implausible that it has not already been said by one philosopher or another.

    Rene DescartesRene Descartes quote #14
  3. Ideas shape the course of history.

    John Maynard KeynesJohn Maynard Keynes quote #19