Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
Claiming that dialectic is primary creates a self‑referential statement that itself can be examined dialectically.
In plain terms
Even the claim about dialectic can be questioned.
What can you take from it?
Question the foundations of any principle.

Where it applies

  • theoretical debate
  • academic writing

Putting it to work

  • apply dialectical critique to core assumptions

Questions to consider

  • Can a principle be beyond critique?

Another view

The statement is abstract and may be inaccessible to many readers.

More from Robert M. Pirsig

  1. When a shepherd goes to kill a wolf, and takes his dog to see the sport, he should take care to avoid mistakes. The dog has certain relationships to the wolf t…

    Permalink to quote #65
  2. Dialectic, which is the parent of logic, came itself from rhetoric. Rhetoric is in turn the child of the myths and poetry of ancient Greece. That is so histori…

    Permalink to quote #67
  3. No one sees it yet, but they will soon enough. The Chairman of the Committee on Analysis of Ideas and Study of Methods has just been shot down in his own class…

    Permalink to quote #64

Related quotes

  1. 'Dialectic thought is an attempt to break through the coercion of logic by its own means.'

    Theodor AdornoTheodor Adorno quote #18
  2. It is quite impossible for a proposition to state that it itself is true. (4.442)

    Ludwig WittgensteinLudwig Wittgenstein quote #20
  3. Dialectic generally means 'of the nature of the dialogue,' which is a conversation between two persons. Nowadays it means logical argumentation. It involves a …

    Robert M. PirsigRobert M. Pirsig quote #40