If a young girl is being forced into a brothel she will not talk about her rights. In such a situation the word would sound ludicrously inadequate. [p.63]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- In extreme oppression like forced prostitution, abstract concepts of rights feel useless and out of touch with reality.
- In plain terms
- Rights talk sounds silly when someone is being forced into slavery.
- What can you take from it?
- Abstract rights fail in extreme survival situations.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When do words fail us?
- What actions matter more than talk?
Another view
Rights frameworks are still necessary even if they feel inadequate in the moment.
More from Simone Weil
If you say to someone who has ears to hear: 'What you are doing to me is not just,' you may touch and awaken at its source the spirit of attention and love. Bu…
Permalink to quote #20 The full expression of personality depends upon its being inflated by social prestige; it is a social privilege. [p.64]
Permalink to quote #22 Rights are always asserted in a tone of contention; and when this tone is adopted, it must rely upon force in the background, or else it will be laughed at. [p…
Permalink to quote #19
Related quotes
Monsters remain human beings. In fact, to reduce them to a subhuman level is to exonerate them of their acts of terrorism and mass murder - just as animals are…
Andrew SullivanAndrew Sullivan quote #1 Mr. Speaker, I would like to ask for a moment of silence here in this chamber to remember our fallen colleague, my predecessor representing the San Francisco P…
Leo J. RyanLeo J. Ryan quote #7 This is not a question of expediency, but of right. In antebellum days the proposition was not, Are the blacks good enough to be free? but, Have they the right…
Voltairine de CleyreVoltairine de Cleyre quote #10