Skip to content
quotesby

This is not a question of expediency, but of right. In antebellum days the proposition was not, Are the blacks good enough to be free? but, Have they the right? So today the question is not, Will outrages result from freeing humanity? but, Has it the right to life, the means of life, the opportunities of happiness? In the transition epoch, surely crimes will come. Did the seed of tyranny ever bear good fruit? And can you expect Liberty to undo in a moment what Oppression has been doing for ages? Criminals are the crop of despots, as much a necessary expression of the evil in society as an ulcer is of disease in the blood; and so long as the taint of the poison remains, so long there will be crimes.

Voltairine de Cleyre#10

FreedomJusticeRightsCrimeOppression

About this quote

What does it mean?
Rights matter more than consequences; crime is a product of oppression, not freedom.
In plain terms
Focus on rights, not outcomes. Crime comes from oppression, not liberty.
What can you take from it?
Justice is about rights, not consequences.

Where it applies

  • social justice debates

Putting it to work

  • advocate for human rights

Questions to consider

  • Is crime a product of freedom?

Another view

Some argue consequences must be weighed alongside rights.

More from Voltairine de Cleyre

  1. I think it can be shown that the law makes ten criminals where it restrains one. On that basis it would not, as a matter of policy merely, be an economical ins…

    Permalink to quote #9
  2. 'For it must needs that offences come, but woe to him through whom the offence cometh.' The crimes of the future are the harvests sown of the ruling classes of…

    Permalink to quote #11
  3. A man won't steal, ordinarily, unless that which he steals is something he cannot as easily get without stealing; in liberty the cost of stealing would involve…

    Permalink to quote #8

Related quotes

  1. If the prosecution of crime is to be conducted with so little regard for that protection which centuries of English law have given to the individual, we are in…

    Learned HandLearned Hand quote #26
  2. There is a subtle difference between being a prisoner and being a slave. I don't mistake either for being free.

    Lois McMaster BujoldLois McMaster Bujold quote #35
  3. We, the undersigned, gathered in Pilgrimage to the capital of the State in Sacramento in penance for all the failings of Farm Workers as free and sovereign men…

    Cesar ChavezCesar Chavez quote #4