A man won't steal, ordinarily, unless that which he steals is something he cannot as easily get without stealing; in liberty the cost of stealing would involve greater difficulties than producing, and consequently he would not be apt to steal. But suppose a man steals. Today you go to a representative of that power which has robbed you of the earth, of the right of free contract of the means of exchange, taxes you for everything you eat or wear (the meanest form of robbery), - you go to him for redress from a thief!
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Stealing arises from scarcity and inequality; seeking redress from the state that causes this scarcity is contradictory.
- In plain terms
- People steal when they cannot get things easily; going to the state for help when it causes the problem is illogical.
- What can you take from it?
- Address root causes of crime rather than punishing individuals.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What causes crime most?
- How do we prevent harm without punishment?
Another view
The quote assumes theft is only economic and ignores other motives.
More from Voltairine de Cleyre
An agent is usually held accountable to his principals. If you do not know the individuals who voted for you, then you do not know for whom you are acting, nor…
Permalink to quote #7 I think it can be shown that the law makes ten criminals where it restrains one. On that basis it would not, as a matter of policy merely, be an economical ins…
Permalink to quote #9 Government is as unreal, as intangible, as unapproachable as God. Try it, if you don't believe it. Seek through the legislative halls of America and find, if y…
Permalink to quote #6
Related quotes
This is not a question of expediency, but of right. In antebellum days the proposition was not, Are the blacks good enough to be free? but, Have they the right…
Voltairine de CleyreVoltairine de Cleyre quote #10 They [the Reagan Administration] want to put street criminals in jail to make life safer for the business criminals. They're against street crime, providing th…
George CarlinGeorge Carlin quote #12 May God inspire these men sometime to come to their senses in regard to God again, so that they may repent, however latter day, of their grave crimes, namely h…
Saint PatrickSaint Patrick quote #12