Skip to content
quotesby

The common run of moralists complain that man is moved by his private self-interest: would to heaven it were so! Private interest is a self-centered principle of action, but at the same time restricted, reasonable and incapable of giving rise to unlimited evils. Whereas, on the other hand, the law of all activities governing social life, except in the case of primitive communities, is that here one sacrifices human life - in himself and in others - to things which are only means to a better way of living. This sacrifice takes on various forms, but it all comes back to the question of power. Power, by definition, is only a means; or to put it better, to possess a power is simply to possess means of action which exceed the very limited force that a single individual has at his disposal. But power-seeking, owing to its essential incapacity to seize hold of its object, rules out all consideration of an end, and finally comes, through an inevitable reversal, to take the place of all ends. It is this reversal of the relationship between means and end, it is this fundamental folly that accounts for all that is senseless and bloody right through history. Human history is simply the history of the servitude which makes men - oppressed and oppressors alike - the plaything of the instruments of domination they themselves have manufactured, and thus reduces living humanity to being the chattel of inanimate chattels. [p.141]

Simone Weil#30

PhilosophyPowerSocietyMoralitySacrificeSocial life

About this quote

What does it mean?
Simone Weil argues that private self-interest is limited and reasonable, whereas the drive for power in social life leads to unlimited evils and sacrifice.
In plain terms
Self-interest is safe because it is limited, but the pursuit of power is dangerous because it demands unlimited sacrifice.
What can you take from it?
Power is a means to act, not an end, yet seeking it often leads to dehumanization.

Where it applies

  • political analysis
  • ethical philosophy
  • social criticism

Putting it to work

  • critique of power structures
  • ethical decision making

Questions to consider

  • Is self-interest truly more humane than power?
  • How do we limit power without stifling action?

Another view

The quote assumes a clear distinction between private interest and power that may not always hold in complex systems.

More from Simone Weil

  1. By a strange mystery - which is connected with the power of the social element - a profession can confer on quite ordinary men in their exercise of it, virtues…

    Permalink to quote #29
  2. Once the experience of war makes visible the possibility of death that lies locked up in each moment, our thoughts cannot travel from one day to the next witho…

    Permalink to quote #31
  3. By committing a crime, a man places himself, of his own accord, outside the chain of eternal obligations which bind every human being to every other one. Punis…

    Permalink to quote #28

Related quotes

  1. From the moment that eternal principles are put in doubt simultaneously with formal virtue, and when every value is discredited, reason will start to act witho…

    Albert CamusAlbert Camus quote #135
  2. Evil is a point of view. God kills indiscriminately and so shall we. For no creatures under God are as we are, none so like him as ourselves.

    Anne RiceAnne Rice quote #4
  3. While the easiest way in metaphysics is to condemn all metaphysics as nonsense, the easiest way in morals is to elevate the common practice of the community in…

    Daniel J. BoorstinDaniel J. Boorstin quote #7