Skip to content
quotesby

Good scholars struggle to understand the world in an integral way (pedants bite off tiny bits and worry them to death). These visions of reality [:] demand our respect, for they are an intellectual's only birthright. They are often entirely wrong and always flawed in serious ways, but they must be understood honorably and not subjected to mayhem by the excision of patches.

Stephen Jay Gould#105

KnowledgeIdeasScholarshipIntegrityIntellectUnderstanding

About this quote

What does it mean?
Scholars who try to understand the whole world deserve respect even if their holistic visions are flawed or wrong.
In plain terms
Respect big pictures even if they are not perfect.
What can you take from it?
Honor holistic visions over fragmented pedantry.

Where it applies

  • academic review
  • intellectual history
  • teaching

Putting it to work

  • evaluate arguments charitably
  • avoid fragmenting ideas

Questions to consider

  • Why do holistic views deserve respect?
  • How should we handle flawed ideas?

Another view

Some fragmented analysis is necessary for accuracy.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. Eugene Dubois is no hero in my book, if only because I share the spirit of his unorthodoxies, but disagree so strongly with his version, and regard his support…

    Permalink to quote #104
  2. Great theories are expansive; failures mire us in dogmatism and tunnel vision.

    Permalink to quote #106
  3. The truly awesome intellectuals in our history have not merely made discoveries; they have woven variegated, but firm, tapestries of comprehensive coverage. Th…

    Permalink to quote #103

Related quotes

  1. 'During Alfven's visit he gave a lecture at the University of Chicago, which was attended by Enrico Fermi. As Alfven described his work, Fermi nodded his head …

    Hannes AlfvenHannes Alfven quote #15
  2. The passion for seeking the truth for truth's sake...can be kept alive only if we continue to seek the truth for truth's sake.

    Franz BoasFranz Boas quote #1
  3. The continuous capacity of genius to surpass understanding remains a human constant.

    Denis DuttonDenis Dutton quote #1