If I choose to impose individual blame for all past social ills, there will be no one left to like in some of the most fascinating periods of our history. For example [:] if I place every Victorian anti-Semite beyond the pale of my attention, my compass of available music and literature will be pitifully small. Though I hold no shred of sympathy for active persecution, I cannot excoriate individuals who acquiesced passively in a standard societal judgment. Rail instead against the judgment, and try to understand what motivates men of decent will.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Judging past figures solely by modern morals limits our access to history and culture.
- In plain terms
- If you reject all old artists for their bad views, you lose their good work.
- What can you take from it?
- Separate societal judgments from individual artists to appreciate their work.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Which old works do you avoid?
- How do you judge past figures?
Another view
Some past harms demand we reject certain figures entirely.
More from Stephen Jay Gould
[W]e do live in a conceptual trough that encourages such yearning for unknown and romanticized greener pastures of other times. The future doesn't seem promisi…
Permalink to quote #109 Yes, Shakespeare foremost and forever (Darwin too). But also teach about the excellence of pygmy bushcraft and Fuegian survival in the world's harshest climate…
Permalink to quote #111 [S]cience is often regarded as the most objective and truth-directed of human enterprises, and since direct observation is supposed to be the favored route to …
Permalink to quote #108
Related quotes
Jung Ritter lere / got lip haben frawen io ere / So wechst dein ere Uebe ritterschaft und lere / kunst dy dich zyret und in krigen sere hofiret Ringens gut fes…
Johannes LichtenauerJohannes Lichtenauer quote #1 In Italy, for thirty years under the Borgias, they had warfare, terror, murder and bloodshed - they produced Michelangelo, Leonardo Da Vinci and the Renaissanc…
Orson WellesOrson Welles quote #2 Despite the hundreds of attempts, police terror and the concentration camps have proved to be more or less impossible subjects for the artist; since what happe…
Al AlvarezAl Alvarez quote #3