I love to read the dedications of old books written in monarchies-for they invariably honor some (usually insignificant) knight or duke with fulsome words of sycophantic insincerity, praising him as the light of the universe (in hopes, no doubt, for a few ducats to support future work); this old practice makes me feel like such an honest and upright man, by comparison, when I put a positive spin, perhaps ever so slightly exaggerated, on a grant proposal.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Gould contrasts the insincere dedications in old books with modern grant proposals, noting that even slight exaggeration in the latter feels honest by comparison.
- In plain terms
- Old book dedications were fake praise for money; modern grant writing is better but still involves some spin.
- What can you take from it?
- Modern academic writing, while flawed, feels more honest than historical flattery.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is academic writing truly honest?
- How has scholarship funding changed?
Another view
Grant proposals can still be highly biased or manipulative despite seeming better than old dedications.
More from Stephen Jay Gould
True majorities, in a TV-dominated and anti-intellectual age, may need sound bites and flashing lights-and I am not against supplying such lures if they draw c…
Permalink to quote #123 My profession often gets bad press for a variety of sins, both actual and imagined: arrogance, venality, insensitivity to moral issues about the use of knowled…
Permalink to quote #125 I have long recognized the theory and aesthetic of such comprehensive display: show everything and incite wonder by sheer variety. But I had never realized how…
Permalink to quote #122
Related quotes
This story is slightly immoral, but so, I guess, are stories based on truth.
Ring LardnerRing Lardner quote #3 The history of the Victorian Age will never be written: we know too much about it. For ignorance is the first requisite of the historian - ignorance, which sim…
Lytton StracheyLytton Strachey quote #3 It is not [the biographer's] business to be complimentary; it is his business to lay bare the facts of the case, as he understands them...dispassionately, impa…
Lytton StracheyLytton Strachey quote #5