Skip to content
quotesby

I love to read the dedications of old books written in monarchies-for they invariably honor some (usually insignificant) knight or duke with fulsome words of sycophantic insincerity, praising him as the light of the universe (in hopes, no doubt, for a few ducats to support future work); this old practice makes me feel like such an honest and upright man, by comparison, when I put a positive spin, perhaps ever so slightly exaggerated, on a grant proposal.

Stephen Jay Gould#124

HistoryTruthEthicsWritingScholarship

About this quote

What does it mean?
Gould contrasts the insincere dedications in old books with modern grant proposals, noting that even slight exaggeration in the latter feels honest by comparison.
In plain terms
Old book dedications were fake praise for money; modern grant writing is better but still involves some spin.
What can you take from it?
Modern academic writing, while flawed, feels more honest than historical flattery.

Where it applies

  • academia
  • publishing
  • grant writing

Putting it to work

  • recognize historical bias
  • str for transparency
  • critique funding models

Questions to consider

  • Is academic writing truly honest?
  • How has scholarship funding changed?

Another view

Grant proposals can still be highly biased or manipulative despite seeming better than old dedications.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. True majorities, in a TV-dominated and anti-intellectual age, may need sound bites and flashing lights-and I am not against supplying such lures if they draw c…

    Permalink to quote #123
  2. My profession often gets bad press for a variety of sins, both actual and imagined: arrogance, venality, insensitivity to moral issues about the use of knowled…

    Permalink to quote #125
  3. I have long recognized the theory and aesthetic of such comprehensive display: show everything and incite wonder by sheer variety. But I had never realized how…

    Permalink to quote #122

Related quotes

  1. This story is slightly immoral, but so, I guess, are stories based on truth.

    Ring LardnerRing Lardner quote #3
  2. The history of the Victorian Age will never be written: we know too much about it. For ignorance is the first requisite of the historian - ignorance, which sim…

    Lytton StracheyLytton Strachey quote #3
  3. It is not [the biographer's] business to be complimentary; it is his business to lay bare the facts of the case, as he understands them...dispassionately, impa…

    Lytton StracheyLytton Strachey quote #5