Skip to content
quotesby

Gould occupies a rather curious position, particularly on this side of the Atlantic. Because of the excellence of his essays, he has come to be seen by non-biologists as the preeminent evolutionary theorist. In contrast, the evolutionary biologists with whom I have discussed his work tend to see him as a man whose ideas are so confused as to be hardly worth bothering with, but as one who should not be publicly criticized because he is at least on our side against the creationists. All this would not matter, were it not that he is giving non-biologists a largely false picture of the state of evolutionary theory.

Stephen Jay Gould#180

ScienceDebateCriticismReputation

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author critiques Gould's reputation, noting a divide between public acclaim and scientific criticism.
In plain terms
Gould is famous to the public but criticized by professional biologists for confused ideas.
What can you take from it?
Be aware of the gap between public reputation and peer review.

Where it applies

  • academic debate
  • public science
  • peer review

Putting it to work

  • evaluating claims
  • understanding scientific consensus

Questions to consider

  • Should science be judged by public popularity?
  • How do we verify expert claims?

Another view

Public reputation often matters more than technical accuracy in broad discourse.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. In all my years of teaching with Steve, I have never seen him flustered or at a loss for words-except once. In our course entitled 'Thinking About Thinking,' h…

    Permalink to quote #179
  2. Now it is not very hard to find out, if you spend a little while reading in evolution, that Gould is the John Kenneth Galbraith of his subject. That is, he is …

    Permalink to quote #181
  3. Steve was one of seven or eight second-year students in Columbia University's graduate program in paleontology. I was a senior at the college, eager to hang ou…

    Permalink to quote #178

Related quotes

  1. 'Huxley gave the death-blow not only to Owen's theory of the skull but also to Owen's hitherto unchallenged prestige'

    Thomas Henry HuxleyThomas Henry Huxley quote #72
  2. My feeling is that Darwinism is only at best a partial solution, and an extremely dangerous partial solution. I would say, based on the little I know, Darwinis…

    Ben SteinBen Stein quote #10
  3. But when I talk to people who are Darwinists or evolutionists and say, 'Well, how did life begin' -- they're...they don't have an answer. I mean, they have an …

    Ben SteinBen Stein quote #18