Skip to content
quotesby

Now it is not very hard to find out, if you spend a little while reading in evolution, that Gould is the John Kenneth Galbraith of his subject. That is, he is a wonderful writer who is beloved by literary intellectuals and lionized by the media because he does not use algebra or difficult jargon. Unfortunately, it appears that he avoids these sins not because he has transcended his colleagues but because he does not seem to understand what they have to say; and his own descriptions of what the field is about-not just the answers, but even the questions-are consistently misleading.

Stephen Jay Gould#181

ScienceCriticismCommunicationAccuracy

About this quote

What does it mean?
A critic argues Gould is popular because he avoids complex math, but claims this makes his descriptions of evolution misleading.
In plain terms
Some say Gould writes well for many but misses deeper math points in evolution.
What can you take from it?
Simplicity in science communication risks losing accuracy.

Where it applies

  • academic review
  • science writing
  • public outreach

Putting it to work

  • check simplifications
  • balance clarity and rigor

Questions to consider

  • Should science be simple?
  • How accurate is popular science?

Another view

Simplification is necessary for public understanding of complex fields.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. Gould occupies a rather curious position, particularly on this side of the Atlantic. Because of the excellence of his essays, he has come to be seen by non-bio…

    Permalink to quote #180
  2. I can't say much about Gould's strengths as a scientist, but for a long time I've regarded him as the second most influential historian of science (next to Tho…

    Permalink to quote #182
  3. In all my years of teaching with Steve, I have never seen him flustered or at a loss for words-except once. In our course entitled 'Thinking About Thinking,' h…

    Permalink to quote #179

Related quotes

  1. From time to time throughout his long life, scientists and commentators dismissed him as a showman. Would that we had a whole troupe of such scientific showmen.

    Linus PaulingLinus Pauling quote #16
  2. I never said it. Honest. Oh, I said there are maybe 100 billion galaxies and 10 billion trillion stars. It's hard to talk about the Cosmos without using big nu…

    Carl SaganCarl Sagan quote #67
  3. If perchance there should be foolish speakers who, together with those ignorant of all mathematics, will take it upon themselves to decide concerning these thi…

    Nicolaus CopernicusNicolaus Copernicus quote #1