Skip to content
quotesby

[Gould's] historical account is highly selective; he asserts the non-objectivity of science so that he can test for scientific truth, flagrantly, by the standards of his own social and political convictions; and by linking his critique to the quest for fairness and justice, he exploits the generous instincts of his readers.: In effect, we see here Lysenkoism risen again: an effort to outlaw a field of science because it conflicts with a political dogma.

Stephen Jay Gould#189

ScienceHistoryTruthBiasPoliticsCritiqueJustice

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author argues that Gould selectively interprets history to fit his political views, using fairness as a cover to suppress scientific fields that disagree with him.
In plain terms
Gould uses political beliefs to judge science, which is like trying to ban science that doesn't match his ideas.
What can you take from it?
Avoid letting personal politics override objective scientific standards.

Where it applies

  • academic debates
  • policy making
  • scientific criticism

Putting it to work

  • evaluate arguments on evidence
  • check for hidden agendas
  • maintain scientific neutrality

Questions to consider

  • Can science ever be truly objective?
  • How do we balance justice and truth?

Another view

The quote assumes Gould's motives are purely political without proving his actual intent.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. Gould's argument on reification purports to get at the philosophical foundation of the field. He claims that general intelligence, defined as the factor common…

    Permalink to quote #188
  2. In his references to my own work, Gould includes at least nine citations that involve more than just an expression of Gould's opinion; in these citations Gould…

    Permalink to quote #190
  3. S. J. Gould's Mismeasure of Man is a paleontologist's distorted view of what psychologists think, untutored in even the most elementary facts of the science. G…

    Permalink to quote #187

Related quotes

  1. You protest, and with justice, each time Hitler jails an opponent; but you forget that Stalin and company have jailed and murdered a thousand times as many. It…

    Upton SinclairUpton Sinclair quote #36
  2. Having fought most of my life against apartheid - and of course my parents were imprisoned during the struggle - I am thrilled by the way South Africa has deve…

    Peter HainPeter Hain quote #1
  3. Stalin's methods did not help.

    Anastas MikoyanAnastas Mikoyan quote #1