Skip to content
quotesby

You protest, and with justice, each time Hitler jails an opponent; but you forget that Stalin and company have jailed and murdered a thousand times as many. It seems to me, and indeed the evidence is plain, that compared to the Moscow brigands and assassins, Hitler is hardly more than a common Ku Kluxer and Mussolini almost a philanthropist.

Upton Sinclair#36

PoliticsHistoryJusticeViolenceAuthoritarianismCritiqueMurder

About this quote

What does it mean?
The speaker argues that Soviet leaders jailed and murdered far more people than Hitler, equating them to common criminals.
In plain terms
Soviet leaders killed more than Hitler.
What can you take from it?
Critique of Stalinist crimes.

Where it applies

  • historical debate
  • political criticism
  • comparing regimes

Putting it to work

  • evaluate totalitarian crimes
  • compare historical leaders

Questions to consider

  • How do you compare historical tyrants?
  • Which crimes are worse?

Another view

Comparing regimes can minimize unique evils.

More from Upton Sinclair

  1. I did not want to say these unpleasant things, but you have written to me, asking my opinion, and I give it to you, flat. If you would get over two ideas - fir…

    Permalink to quote #35
  2. I have regarded you, not as a novelist, but as an historian; for it is my considered opinion, unshaken at 85, that records of fact are not history. They are on…

    Permalink to quote #37
  3. I look upon Upton Sinclair as one of the greatest novelists in the world, the Zola of America.

    Permalink to quote #34

Related quotes

  1. [Gould's] historical account is highly selective; he asserts the non-objectivity of science so that he can test for scientific truth, flagrantly, by the standa…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #189
  2. Having fought most of my life against apartheid - and of course my parents were imprisoned during the struggle - I am thrilled by the way South Africa has deve…

    Peter HainPeter Hain quote #1
  3. Stalin's methods did not help.

    Anastas MikoyanAnastas Mikoyan quote #1