Skip to content
quotesby

I have regarded you, not as a novelist, but as an historian; for it is my considered opinion, unshaken at 85, that records of fact are not history. They are only annals, which cannot become historical until the artist-poet-philosopher rescues them from the unintelligible chaos of their actual occurrence and arranges them in works of art. When people ask me what has happened in my long lifetime I do not refer them to the newspaper files and to the authorities, but to your novels. They object that the people in your books never existed; that their deeds were never done and their sayings never uttered. I assure them that they were, except that Upton Sinclair individualized and expressed them better than they could have done, and arranged their experiences, which as they actually occurred were as unintelligible as pied type, in significant and intelligible order.

Upton Sinclair#37

TruthArtHistoryFictionMemory

About this quote

What does it mean?
Historical records are just facts; art and philosophy must organize them into intelligible stories to become true history, which is why novels often explain life better than newspapers.
In plain terms
Facts alone aren't history; artists must arrange them into meaningful stories for people to understand.
What can you take from it?
Art transforms raw facts into understandable history.

Where it applies

  • historical writing
  • reading fiction
  • understanding past

Putting it to work

  • read novels for insight
  • value storytelling over facts

Questions to consider

  • Is fiction more truthful than history?
  • How do we remember the past?

Another view

Novels may prioritize meaning over strict factual accuracy.

More from Upton Sinclair

  1. You protest, and with justice, each time Hitler jails an opponent; but you forget that Stalin and company have jailed and murdered a thousand times as many. It…

    Permalink to quote #36
  2. I have never known a novel that was good enough to be good in spite of its being adapted to the author's political views.

    Permalink to quote #38
  3. I did not want to say these unpleasant things, but you have written to me, asking my opinion, and I give it to you, flat. If you would get over two ideas - fir…

    Permalink to quote #35

Related quotes

  1. Both of them were artists with highly developed personas, and hence unreliable witnesses to their own pasts.

    Wilfrid SheedWilfrid Sheed quote #21
  2. Fiction has to be plausible. All history has to do is happen.

    Harry TurtledoveHarry Turtledove quote #1
  3. Poetry, even when apparently most fantastic, is always a revolt against artifice, a revolt, in a sense, against actuality. It speaks of what seems fantastic an…

    James JoyceJames Joyce quote #1