Skip to content
quotesby

A complete theory of evolution must acknowledge a balance between 'external' forces of environment imposing selection for local adaptation and 'internal' forces representing constraints of inheritance and development. Vavilov placed too much emphasis on internal constraints and downgraded the power of selection. But Western Darwinians have erred equally in practically ignoring (while acknowledging in theory) the limits placed on selection by structure and development-what Vavilov and the older biologists would have called 'laws of form.'

Stephen Jay Gould#31

EvolutionBiologySelection

About this quote

What does it mean?
Evolution requires both environmental selection and internal biological constraints. Gould criticizes both Vavilov and Western Darwinians for ignoring one side of this balance.
In plain terms
Evolution depends on outside pressures and inside limits.
What can you take from it?
Consider both environment and biology when studying change.

Where it applies

  • scientific debate
  • theory critique
  • biology class

Putting it to work

  • analyze evolutionary theory
  • study developmental constraints

Questions to consider

  • How do internal limits shape evolution?
  • What did Darwinians ignore?

Another view

It oversimplifies the complex debate between different biological schools.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. Thus, we have three principles for increasing adequacy of data: if you must work with a single object, look for imperfections that record historical descent; i…

    Permalink to quote #30
  2. We do not inhabit a perfected world where natural selection ruthlessly scrutinizes all organic structures and then molds them for optimal utility. Organisms in…

    Permalink to quote #32
  3. Organisms [...] are directed and limited by their past. They must remain imperfect in their form and function, and to that extent unpredictable since they are …

    Permalink to quote #29

Related quotes

  1. Throughout his last half-dozen books, for example, Arthur Koestler has been conducting a campaign against his own misunderstanding of Darwinism. He hopes to fi…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #17
  2. Wallace's error on human intellect arose from the inadequacy of his rigid selectionism, not from a failure to apply it. And his argument repays our study today…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #18
  3. One general law, leading to the advancement of all organic beings, namely, multiply, vary, let the strongest live and the weakest die.

    Charles DarwinCharles Darwin quote #28