Skip to content
quotesby

[H]istorical science is not worse, more restricted, or less capable of achieving firm conclusions because experiment, prediction, and subsumption under invariant laws of nature do not represent its usual working methods. The sciences of history use a different mode of explanation, rooted in the comparative and observational richness in our data. We cannot see a past event directly, but science is usually based on inference, not unvarnished observation (you don't see electrons, gravity, or black holes either).

Stephen Jay Gould#76

ScienceHistoryMethodologyObservationScientific method

About this quote

What does it mean?
Historical science achieves firm conclusions through comparative and observational data rather than experimentation or prediction under invariant laws.
In plain terms
History-based sciences work differently than experimental ones but are just as capable of proving things.
What can you take from it?
Different scientific methods can yield equally valid results.

Where it applies

  • evaluating historical claims
  • understanding science types
  • debating scientific rigor

Putting it to work

  • analyze observational data
  • value comparative methods
  • avoid methodological bias

Questions to consider

  • How do we validate knowledge without direct observation?
  • What makes a scientific conclusion firm?

Another view

Some critics argue that without experimental control, historical conclusions remain less certain.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. All interesting issues in natural history are questions of relative frequency, not single examples. Everything happens once amidst the richness of nature. But …

    Permalink to quote #75
  2. The divine tape recorder holds a million scenarios, each perfectly sensible. Little quirks at the outset, occurring for no particular reason, unleash cascades …

    Permalink to quote #77
  3. The legends of fieldwork locate all important sites deep in inaccessible jungles inhabited by fierce beasts and restless natives, and surrounded by miasmas of …

    Permalink to quote #74

Related quotes

  1. I have not been able to discover the cause of those properties of gravity from phenomena, and I frame no hypotheses;' for whatever is not deduced from the phen…

    Isaac NewtonIsaac Newton quote #3
  2. 'The issue of 'science' does not intrude itself directly upon the occasion of the performance of a musical work, at least a non-electronically produced work, s…

    Milton BabbittMilton Babbitt quote #5
  3. History, like a vast river, propels logs, vegetation, rafts, and debris; it is full of live and dead things, some destined for resurrection; it mingles many wa…

    Jacques BarzunJacques Barzun quote #11