Skip to content
quotesby

Why, when murder now is stalking in your streets, when dens of infamy are so thick within your city that competition has forced down the price of prostitution to the level of the wages of your starving shirt makers; when robbers sit in State and national Senate and House, when the boasted 'bulwark of our liberties,' the elective franchise, has become a U. S. dice-box, wherewith great gamblers play away your liberties; when debauchees of the worst type hold all your public offices and dine off the food of fools who support them, why, then, sits Moses Harman there within his prison cell? If he is so great a criminal, why is he not with the rest of the spawn of crime, dining at Delmonico's or enjoying a trip to Europe? If he is so bad a man, why in the name of wonder did he ever get in the penitentiary? ... He looked, this obscenist looked with clear eyes into this ill-got thing you call morality, sealed with the seal of marriage, and saw in it the consummation of immorality, impurity, and injustice. He beheld every married woman what she is, a bonded slave, who takes her master's name, her master's bread, her master's commands, and serves her master's passion; who passes through the ordeal of pregnancy and the throes of travail at his dictation, not at her desire; who can control no property, not even her own body, without his consent, and from whose straining arms the children she bears may be torn at his pleasure, or willed away while they are yet unborn. It is said the English language has a sweeter word than any other, - home. But Moses Harman looked beneath the word and saw the fact, - a prison more horrible than that where he is sitting now, whose corridors radiate over all the earth, and with so many cells, that none may count them.

Voltairine de Cleyre#12

JusticeHypocrisyCorruption

About this quote

What does it mean?
De Cleyre questions why a reformer like Harman is imprisoned while actual criminals and corrupt politicians thrive in society.
In plain terms
Why is a reformer jailed when worse criminals run the government?
What can you take from it?
Prisons often target reformers rather than the truly corrupt.

Where it applies

  • critiquing prison systems
  • analyzing political corruption

Putting it to work

  • advocating for legal reform
  • exposing societal hypocrisy

Questions to consider

  • Who defines crime in society?
  • Why are some punished while others thrive?

Another view

The quote assumes a clear distinction between criminals and reformers that may not always hold.

More from Voltairine de Cleyre

  1. 'For it must needs that offences come, but woe to him through whom the offence cometh.' The crimes of the future are the harvests sown of the ruling classes of…

    Permalink to quote #11
  2. That is adultery where woman submits herself sexually to man, without desire on her part, for the sake of 'keeping him virtuous,' 'keeping him at home,' the wo…

    Permalink to quote #13
  3. This is not a question of expediency, but of right. In antebellum days the proposition was not, Are the blacks good enough to be free? but, Have they the right…

    Permalink to quote #10

Related quotes

  1. A prowde hert in a beggers brest, A fowle visage with gay temples of atyre, Horrible othes with an holy prist, A justice of juges to selle and lete to hyre, A …

    John LydgateJohn Lydgate quote #3
  2. The formula for prison is a lack of space counterbalanced by a surplus of time.

    Joseph BrodskyJoseph Brodsky quote #2
  3. OH! hear a pensive captive's prayer, For liberty that sighs ; And never let thine heart be shut Against the prisoner's cries.

    Anna Letitia BarbauldAnna Letitia Barbauld quote #2