Skip to content
quotesby

In every remodelling of the present, the existing condition of things must be supplanted by a new one. Now every variety of circumstances in which men find themselves, every object which surrounds them, communicates a definite form and impress to their internal nature. This form is not such that it can change and adapt itself to any other a man may choose to receive; and the end is foiled, while the power is destroyed, when we attempt to impose upon that which is already stamped in the soul a form which disagrees with it.

Wilhelm von Humboldt#17

PowerChangeReformAdaptationIdentity

About this quote

What does it mean?
Changing society requires replacing old conditions, but forcing new forms on people destroys their existing identity.
In plain terms
You can't force people to change their inner nature just by changing outside conditions.
What can you take from it?
Respect existing identities when implementing change.

Where it applies

  • social reform
  • organizational change
  • personal transformation

Putting it to work

  • consult affected groups
  • allow gradual adaptation
  • respect existing culture

Questions to consider

  • How much identity can change before losing self?
  • Is imposed change ever beneficial?

Another view

Change without respect for identity can lead to stagnation.

More from Wilhelm von Humboldt

  1. Every development of truths which relate to human nature, and more especially its active manifestations, is attended with a wish to see worked out in practice …

    Permalink to quote #16
  2. If we glance at the most important revolutions in history, we are at no loss to perceive that the greatest number of these originated in the periodical revolut…

    Permalink to quote #18
  3. All political arrangements, in that they have to bring a variety of widely-discordant interests into unity and harmony, necessarily occasion manifold collision…

    Permalink to quote #15

Related quotes

  1. The New Women! I could barely recognize them as being of the same sex as myself:They are satiated by everything, hungry for nothing. They are what I wanted to …

    Fay WeldonFay Weldon quote #3
  2. I have gone to a safe house, as they say, so I might as well have a different name

    Tony BanksTony Banks quote #5
  3. It's not the career politicians that I care about. I want to get them out just like Arnold did in California, and, after that, we'll get the Californians out o…

    Kinky FriedmanKinky Friedman quote #11