One might say that every fine story must leave in the mind of the sensitive reader an intangible residuum of pleasure; a cadence, a quality of voice that is exclusively the writer's own, individual, unique. A quality which one can remember without the volume at hand, can experience over and over again in the mind but can never absolutely define, as one can experience in memory a melody, or the summer perfume of a garden... It is a common fallacy that a writer, if he is talented enough, can achieve this poignant quality by improving upon his subject-matter, by using his 'imagination' upon it and twisting it to suit his purpose. The truth is that by such a process (which is not imaginative at all!) he can at best produce only a brilliant sham, which, like a badly built and pretentious house, looks poor and shabby after a few years. If he achieves anything noble, anything enduring, it must be by giving himself absolutely to his material. And this gift of sympathy is his great gift; is the fine thing in him that alone can make his work fine. The artist spends a lifetime in pursuing the things that haunt him, in having his mind 'teased' by them, in trying to get these conceptions down on paper exactly as they are to him and not in conventional poses supposed to reveal their character; trying this method and that, as a painter tries different lightings and different attitudes with his subject to catch the one that presents it more suggestively than any other. And at the end of a lifetime he emerges with much that is more or less happy experimenting, and comparatively little that is the very flower of himself and his genius.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Enduring stories leave an intangible pleasure like a melody; forcing imagination on subjects creates shallow work.
- In plain terms
- Great stories linger like music; forcing plots creates cheap work.
- What can you take from it?
- Let the subject speak; don't force your imagination on it.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What story stays with you like a song?
- How do you measure lasting quality?
Another view
Sometimes deliberate plot manipulation is necessary for narrative structure.
More from Willa Cather
To note an artist's limitations is but to define his talent. A reporter can write equally well about everything that is presented to his view, but a creative w…
Permalink to quote #75 The 'sayings' of a community, its proverbs, are its characteristic comment upon life; they imply its history, suggest its attitude toward the world and its way…
Permalink to quote #77 There is a popular superstition that 'realism' asserts itself in the cataloguing of a great number of material objects, in explaining mechanical processes, the…
Permalink to quote #74
Related quotes
I am always at a loss to know how much to believe of my own stories.
Washington IrvingWashington Irving quote #2 Sometimes I get the start of a story from a memory, an anecdote, but that gets lost and is usually unrecognizable in the final story.
Alice MunroAlice Munro quote #8 That is the best story he could find in his life, never mind if it's the truest: an artist's duty is always to tell the best story.
Wilfrid SheedWilfrid Sheed quote #29