Skip to content
quotesby

One need not have been raised in Fresno to appreciate Saroyan, though I suppose it helps. Certainly he, better than anybody, captured the valley's strange texture: the mishmash landscape of farm, town and deserts; the jostling of so many different peoples, all a bit bewildered at finding themselves thrown together ... Certainly Fresnans never forgave Saroyan for his harsher observations about the old hometown. The more political Armenians complained he wasted too many words on the human comedy, and not enough on the tragedy of a lost homeland. That he wrote so personally, and from the heart, gave literary critics their target: He was, they scolded, an undisciplined sentimentalist, mawkish. ... For whatever reasons, Saroyan today is held under book-land quarantine. Few of his titles are in print. He's barely taught in schools. His own plans for literary legacy - a writers-in-residence program, posthumous publication of many works - have been scrapped or stalled. They did name a theater after him in Fresno, the one thing he expressly requested not be done. Those who remain under the Saroyan spell can only hope that the world will come around. His work simply seems too extraordinary, and universal, to be cleared from the shelves...

William Saroyan#177

LiteratureLegacyCriticism

About this quote

What does it mean?
The text discusses the complex reception of Saroyan's work, noting its capture of a specific place but also criticism for sentimentality and lack of political focus.
In plain terms
Saroyan was loved for capturing his hometown but criticized for being too emotional.
What can you take from it?
Artists face mixed reviews based on style and politics.

Where it applies

  • literary critique
  • regional writing
  • legacy planning

Putting it to work

  • teaching literature
  • critique analysis
  • biography

Questions to consider

  • What makes a writer's legacy last?

Another view

It presents a one-sided view of literary criticism.

More from William Saroyan

  1. I'm reminded of the incident in the early 1950s when a suddenly-timorous Jack Kerouac reportedly met Saroyan and exclaimed, 'So you're the man who wrote 'The S…

    Permalink to quote #176
  2. He was the first writer I fell in love with, boyishly in love. I was held by his unaffected voice, his sentimentality, his defiant individualism. I found mysel…

    Permalink to quote #178
  3. Saroyan's output from 1934 to 1940 established his reputation. What enthralled critics and readers was the brashness and certainty of his daring: Beginning wit…

    Permalink to quote #175

Related quotes

  1. For the judging of contemporary literature the only test is one's personal taste. If you much like a new book, you must call it literature even though you find…

    Ford Madox FordFord Madox Ford quote #5
  2. Most of us balk at her soporific rigmaroles, her echolaliac incantations, her half-witted-sounding catalogues on numbers; most of us read her less and less. Ye…

    Gertrude SteinGertrude Stein quote #119
  3. Dickens attacked English institutions with a ferocity that has never since been approached. Yet he managed to do it without making himself hated, and, more tha…

    Charles DickensCharles Dickens quote #157